Take the 2-minute tour ×
Musical Practice & Performance Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for musicians, students, and enthusiasts. It's 100% free, no registration required.

What is the difference between a baritone and a euphonium, and how can you tell? My band director sometimes uses them interchangeably, but I am pretty sure that is not correct. All I know is that this has to do with different valving.

share|improve this question
    
No one mentioned this, but there's a difference in the mouthpieces as well. –  Garan Jul 26 '13 at 13:20

7 Answers 7

In the British Brass Band Tradition, the Baritone is a member of the Saxhorn family, whereas the Euphonium is a member of the Tuba family.

The Euphonium has a wider bore and a more conical flare over more of the instrument's length, compared to the smaller, shorter Baritone flare. Generally, most Reasonable Euphoniums in the UK will have 4 Valves, arranged 3 upright and one on the side, whereas Baritones would have 3 Valves, although 4 Valve Baritones are now available and used in some Brass Bands.

In standard British Brass Bands, there are 2 Euphoniums and 2 Baritones, usually sitting together and frequently playing the same part. Because of the difference in bore and bell size, the Euphonium tends to have a more mellow sound, although the instruments do blend very effectively in the middle of the Band.

Modern Composers are starting to write for the Baritone as a separate instrument, often as a downward extension of the Tenor Horn section. The Euphoniums, likewise, tend to be written as an upward extension of the Tuba (Bass) Section.

In British Brass Bands, both instruments are written as Bb instruments in Treble Clef.

The old trick (in the UK) for telling the difference between a 3 Valve Baritone and a 3 Valve Euphonium was to take out the main Tuning Slide, turn it round, and try to insert the slide with the legs in the opposite hole. If it fits, it's a Baritone. If it doesn't, it's a Euphonium. This may not apply in other locations! :-)

Dave Werden's Site makes a good reference to differences and similarities between the two instruments and also has pictures of the different British and American Instruments..

Darryl (Played Baritone in Brass Bands for 5 years, Euphonium for 2)

EEb Bass Tuba, Shepherd Group Brass Band, York UK

share|improve this answer

Cody's summary of the differences between what you will generally find in an instrument called a "Euphonium" vs. one called a "baritone" is mostly spot on for today, but traditionally there really wasn't a difference between the two and it is a recent phenomenon where the high-end instruments are called euphoniums while cheaper student instruments are called baritones. There were 3-valve euphoniums for a long time, though now 4 vs. 3 valves is the most common differentiation among the two. The baritone horn also exists in a front-facing, compact "marching baritone" style which looks quite different but plays similarly. British band composers tended to label their parts "euphonium" since around the turn of the century, while American composers seem to more often have gone with "baritone" often as "baritone (T.C.)" or "baritone (B.C.)" to accommodate performers who were used to reading in either treble or bass clef. Holst's Euphonium part in the First Suite is written in bass clef in the score; but he provides parts in both treble and bass clefs. Notably while the score says "Euphonium" the parts say "Euphonium (Baritone)." When written in treble clef, both the baritone and euphonium play as transposing B-flat instruments (sounding down a Major-9th, like a bass clarinet or tenor saxophone). In bass clef, they sound as written.

EDIT: Here's an ad from from Boosey & Hawkes which used to make instruments including euphoniums (and sexist ads, apparently) showing a three-valve instrument called a euphonium.

Boosey Euphonium

share|improve this answer
    
1+ for the history –  Cody Guldner Apr 17 '13 at 16:18
    
Thanks @CodyGuldner. I added a photo to give a bit more supporting evidence. –  Michael Scott Cuthbert Apr 18 '13 at 2:09

Baritone

  • Smaller Bore
  • Cylindrical
    • Tubing size stays same until it reaches the bell
  • 3 valves
  • Usually only found in brass bands
  • Cutting and "solo" sound

Baritone

Euphonium

  • Common to find bass clef parts
  • Conical
    • Tubing progressively gets wider as it approaches the bell
  • 4 valves
  • Deeper cut mouthpiece
  • Darker sound
  • Traditional concert instrument

Euphonium

Similarities

  • Both may read Treble or Bass Clef
share|improve this answer
4  
Some of your differences seem not quite right, so both instruments belong to the saxhorn family and have a conical-bore, also the number of valves allows no reliable distinction. I'll try an update after some research. –  guidot Apr 16 '13 at 7:21
    
I play in a brass band and I've never seen a euph or bari like either of your photos! –  Dan Hulme Apr 19 '13 at 14:38
    
Great edit + pictures. –  Michael Scott Cuthbert Apr 20 '13 at 16:28
2  
Also, a baritone is conical, like other Sax horns, not cylindrical. You can clearly see this in your photo! –  Dan Hulme Apr 30 '13 at 7:39

While not disagreeing with tubadaz's great answer, historians often quibble about the origins of various brass horns, and these horns have no shortage of ambiguity over their history. It's no secret that the terms are commonly mixed; a Google Image search for "Baritone Horn" yields a large number of instruments more correctly called euphoniums.

The modern baritone horn is derived from a family of narrowly-conically-bored instruments known as saxhorns. tubadaz says they are cylindrically-bored instruments, but he's technically incorrect on that; they're just not as conical as a horn, euphonium or tuba (though more so than the trumpet or trombone, which are typically held up as examples of "cylindrical bores").

They were invented in the early 1830s by Adolphe Sax, also the father of the saxophone. His vision was to replace the menagerie of brass horns, all of varying regional and cultural origin, with one system of instrument design and construction; 3 edge-mounted dual-piston valves, circular piping arrangement, long straight conical bell, played with a circular cup mouthpiece. The resulting instruments could then be switched between more easily by players as the need arose, unlike the differing mouthpieces, valve designs and orientations of other brass families

He was modestly successful; the family contains ancestors of the modern cornet (sopranino), flugelhorn (soprano), and mellophone (alto), as well as the alto/tenor horn and baritone horn which have changed very little (the main change being a switch from horizontal orientation with rearward bells, popular in marching bands in the Civil War era, to vertical orientation with upward- or forward-facing bells). The bass saxhorn has fallen into disuse, though elements of its design can be seen in some styles of tuba. The baritone horn falls in a gradient of tone with other instruments of the same general range; it's slightly more conically-bored and therefore slightly warmer-sounding than the cylindrically-bored trombone, but brighter and edgier than the Wagner tuba and euphonium.

The euphonium has a different design path; the intent, from the beginning, was to create a baritone-range instrument with a warmer, sweeter timbre than that of existing tenor instruments like the trombone and saxhorns, more like the French horn and its contrabass helicon cousin (the predecessor to the modern sousaphone and ultimately the concert tuba). This was accomplished by scaling down and rearranging the helicon's circular construction while keeping its wide conical cross-section. Wagner had the same idea after hearing Sax's baritone saxhorn; his creation was the Wagner tuba, achieved by scaling up the French horn Wagner sought to emulate at lower registers. Some euphoniums have three valves, similar to the baritone horn, but the majority nowadays have four, adding the "trigger" valve from the French horn and "double Wagner tuba" which lowers the instruments fundamental by a perfect fourth. As the thumb is typically needed to support a euphonium near the valve tree, this fourth valve is usually either a "pinky valve" similar to modern tubas, or a "compensating" valve on the side of the instrument, used by the index finger of the "non-valve" hand.

So, the big differences between a true baritone horn and a euphonium are:

  • Baritone horn virtually always has three valves, in standard configuration; modern euphoniums almost always have four, the extra being more or less the same total length as the first and third combined
  • Baritone horn has a narrower bore than the euphonium for most of its length, with the conical expansion becoming most prevalent only at the bell
  • Baritone horn is typically more compactly coiled, with valves exposed over the top of the downtube leading to the bell, while euphoniums typically have their valves placed underneath the topmost section of the main pipe
  • Baritone horn has a more focused, edgy tone than the mellower euphonium
  • Baritone horn is lighter; for this reason it's more often given to beginning students to learn on, before "graduating" to the euphonium's greater weight and extra valve
  • Baritone horns typically cost less due to less material and surface area to be worked during construction (this is a rather broad statement and there is considerable overlap; you can find many examples of euphoniums costing less than baritones if you look, but these are generally not "apples to apples" comparisons in terms of features and build quality)
  • Baritone horns cannot play their fundamental frequency, which for a Bb instrument is the Bb two leger lines and a space below the bass staff; this is a side effect of the narrower cross section. Euphoniums can play this note without valves; tubas have the same written fundamental note, but like the double bass they sound an octave lower than traditionally scored

The similarities:

  • Core range is virtually identical, other than the loss of the fundamental partial on the baritone; they can be used interchangeably for most military band arrangements.
  • Both can be scored on bass or treble clef (historically the "tenor clef" was also used; this clef is still seen from time to time for trombone but is seldom used for horns).
  • Basic technique, embouchure, breath supply needed, etc are all more or less identical. Again, this makes the baritone horn a good first step for low brass students
share|improve this answer
    
Ah, the answer I've been longing for! Excellent! Can you perhaps refer to sources for further reading? –  Ulf Åkerstedt Nov 5 '13 at 9:07

There's some good information above, as well as some confusing details, in this perennial discussion, but many errors still persist.

For example, at the end of one quote above --

Baritone horns cannot play their fundamental frequency *[-- Actually, they can! -- see below * ] which for a Bb instrument is the Bb two leger lines and a space below the bass staff; this is a side effect of the narrower cross section. [If they CAN play the fundamental, then the supposed side effect is a moot point.] Euphoniums can play this note without valves; tubas have the same written fundamental note [NO! a BBb tuba sounds BBb, contra Bb as a fundamental note for its "open" 18-foot tube length], but like the double bass they sound an octave lower than traditionally scored [NO, they sound at actual pitch and are written one octave below the baritone/euphonium. Treble clef is a different story -- octave-above-the-fundamental middle c, for a Bb cornet sounds Bb 1 step below; for a baritone/euph it sounds a major 9th lower, and for a BBb tuba, it sounds 2 octaves and one step lower. ]*

*Of course the baritone can play the fundamental! It may depend on the player, however. The bore size and shape have nothing to do with that! I can play that same fundamental on a baroque trumpet crooked to Bb (9-foot sounding length), and, comparatively, it's bore is much smaller, and so is the mouthpiece. Mouthpiece cup shape and size, and bore shape and size, might make it easier or more difficult, but it doesn't preclude the fundamental being played. In fact, you can get the fundamental on any lip-vibrated aerophone merely by tapping the mouthpiece with the palm of your hand!

Also -- let's add the "North American" terminology into the discussion -- What about the tenor horn? Even narrower bore than the baritone. And many old band parts just say "baritone" meaning whatever plays in that range. Often the distinction was more what clef it played -- treble clef = baritone, bass clef = euphonium.

Another misconception - Tubas are also saxhorns, and all saxhorns are flugelhorns (meaning more or less conical in bore shape). Here are more terms to define (or maybe NOT! :-) ) -- Bass tuba; Contra bass tuba (in my book the same thing); Bb Bass (in mid-19th century, a wide bore "euphonium" often over-the-shoulder); Bb Baritone (in mid-19th century, a medium-wide bore "baritone" often over-the-shoulder); Bb Tenor (in mid-19th century, a more narrow bore "baritone" or tenor horn, often over-the-shoulder); "Bb Tenor" could also imply a treble clef valved (or not) trombone! a term often used in British brass band arrangements; Bb alto is sometimes a name given to the Bb cornet, and/or Flugelhorn.

I have many instruments in my collection in the 9-foot and 18-foot range (and in between) that would defy being pigeonholed into anyone's preset terminology. I have a right-shouldered (but still right handed for valves) helicon, a baritone Centennial horn (which might be classed as a valved bass trombone), and German Band instruments in oval shape with small and large bores. The original name for a double belled euphonium was the doublophone and it was classed as a euphonium and valve trombone in one instrument. I played it today at our Tuba Christmas concert and got brighter sounds from the small bell, and darker sounds from the big bell. It is a York, and it would probably be termed a baritone by the pigeonholers. I also have Bueschers and Conns with 4 and 5 valves, with otherwise identical bore shapes and diameters, and additional DB euphs by other makers.

So let's just make music on the things, and stop arguing about terminology (but let's get the acoustic facts correct).

Just my two cents, from a guy with 6000 instruments, who plays in vintage brass bands, and leads the Plumbing Factory Brass Band in London Canada.

Dr. Hank

(AKA Henry Meredith)

share|improve this answer
    
Welcome to the site! On Stack Exchange, your reputation comes from contributing lots of good questions and answers (like this one!), as indicated by the number next to your name. You can put your credentials in your profile page if you wish. Since everyone can edit every answer on this site, and since your posts are automatically signed, the signature you included at the end of this post is likely to be edited out by another user. –  NReilingh Dec 8 '13 at 3:02

Baritones in a typical British heritage brass band (as here in Australia) are Cylindrical bore in the same manner that trumpets (as opposed to cornets) and trombones are, while Euphoniums are conical bore.

Baritones are also generally smaller than Euphoniums allowing them to have a high range for the average player.

Having said all of that, I'm a firm believer that Euphoniums produce a much nicer sound in the ensemble on the baritone parts if the player is up to it.

In a concert band the Euphonium is universally called a Baritone due to its register only.

share|improve this answer

The differences between a Baritone and a Euphonium is that a baritone is the same size tubing until the very end, then it gets wider. A euphonium gradually gets bigger throughout the horn. If an instrument has four valves, it is usually a euphonium.

share|improve this answer

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.