Take the 2-minute tour ×
Music: Practice & Theory Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for musicians, students, and enthusiasts. It's 100% free, no registration required.

I am doing "spider exercise" from JOHN PATITUCCI Bass Workshop 1 3 Left Hand Dexterity Builders chunk 1, After a couple of minutes I start feeling increasing left thumb tension, in 10 minutes it becomes almost painful. Is it inevitable for guitar beginners or my left hand position is wrong? Should I find a teacher to place my hands correctly? Or are there any useful video guides on the subject?

share|improve this question

2 Answers 2

up vote 5 down vote accepted

As with any dexterity exercise, slow it down!

Your hands are likely hurting because you're trying to push them too hard to either:

  • stretch while playing (you should always be doing this before playing)
  • keep up with the exercise speed
  • emulate the sound exactly (for a beginner, this is exceeding difficult)
  • or fret too heavily

as with the answer above me, give it a rest when your hands start to hurt, but frankly, anyone's hands should be able to play for about 10 minutes without major pain if they're playing to their skill level. Working your hands out is good, but you should NEVER walk away in pain, cramps are common, some soreness is to be expected if you push, but if you're actually in pain, you're doing something wrong.

Try slowing down the exercise, or working on your fretting. The biggest detriment to a player's speed (and their hands!) that I've found is that they're just fretting too hard.

Once you find the 'Sweet Spot' for fretting (the place where you can hold the note without much effort beyond that), your speed will increase dramatically. The way I used to work on this is by fretting a note, and slowly releasing pressure from my finger and striking the string. Do this until you start hearing your string buzz against the frets, then add a little more pressure until it stops buzzing. This area where its not buzzing is the 'Sweet Spot'.

Try working on that in tandem with the exercise you're doing now, and you should start noticing some real progress, and you should start noticing your playing beginning to sound similar to the exercise.

Good luck.

share|improve this answer
    
Playing the spider slowly is way harder but it helps A LOT in the progress. Good point! –  Shevliaskovic Dec 8 '13 at 22:13
    
I haven't run into anything thats more difficult to play slower so far, I'll have to check this out, I've been hunting for a good timing challenge! –  WeRelic Dec 8 '13 at 22:54
    
Probably you are right - I thought that I just need to fret hard enough to avoid string buzzing. Will try to find 'sweet spot', thank you very much! –  Alex M. Dec 9 '13 at 11:38
    
Good luck! It takes patience, but its well worth it in the end. You have part of the equation already, its just a matter of fine tuning. If you fret too hard, you wear your hands down and can change the tone of the note(very slightly), avoiding the fret buzz is the main part when you start out, then you tone it back till fretting feels almost effortless(at least compared to how you were fretting before) –  WeRelic Dec 9 '13 at 20:16

Golden rule: When you hurt, stop! You don't want to damage your hand. It might make you stop playing music for ever!

The spider as you said is for building dexterity. Hence, at first it will hurt if you are a beginner.

But think of it as this: When you start running to build dexterity (and you are out of shape), you won't be able to run for a long time at first. You will run for 5-10 minutes and when you get tired, you will stop for 2-3 minutes. Then you will start again and do the same thing.

You should do the same thing with the spider exercise. Work it for 5 minutes and when you start to hurt, stop and do some stretching exercises for your hand for a a couple of minutes. Then play the spider again for 5 minutes then stop again etc...

It's really important to stop when you are painfully hurt, because it could some serious damage to your hand.

It would be good to get a teacher if you could afford one, cos he'll be able to tell you some technical mistakes you might be making that would result in false techniques.

share|improve this answer

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.