Take the 2-minute tour ×
Music: Practice & Theory Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for musicians, students, and enthusiasts. It's 100% free, no registration required.

An effect that many electronic music creators go for is a "dirty bass synth" or something similar. What exactly does this term mean, if it has a precise definition at all? What qualities of a synth make it dirty?

From what I know, it's supposed to have a rough sort of sound, but that's about it.

share|improve this question

4 Answers 4

up vote 16 down vote accepted

Terminology

  • Every sound is composed of one or more sine waves.

  • From that group of sine waves, the one with the lowest frequency is called the fundamental, every other sine wave above that one is called an overtone.

  • Overtones that are integer multiples of the fundamental are called harmonics. The fundamental is considered a harmonic, the first harmonic, but not an overtone.

  • The characteristics of these overtones (like quantity, amplitude, and frequency) is what gives each sound a specific timbre. That's why a guitar and a piano sound different, even when playing the same note.

What is a "dirty" sound?

It's all about the overtones.

  • How many overtones. A sound with more overtones will tend to sound dirtier than one with less overtones.

  • Frequency of the overtones and their relation with the fundamental. From two sounds with equal quantity of overtones, the one with less harmonics (less overtones that are integer multiples of the fundamental) will tend to be perceived as dirtier.

  • Loudness of the overtones. The loudest overtones will have a bigger influence in the timber of a sound than the quieter ones.

So, it is about both quantity and quality.

These 3 are what I consider the most important dynamics that define the dirtiness of a sound.

There's a more in-depth, scientific, concept called auditory roughness introduced by Helmholtz in 1885 which takes other things into consideration, like amplitude fluctuations of the spectrum and pitch instability. You can read more about it here, here, and here.

Seeing and hearing overtones, dirty and clean sounds

(check your sound levels before playing these)

This is how a sine wave sounds like:

https://soundcloud.com/jcpedroza/sine-wave-in-c-523-25hz

This is how a square wave sounds like:

Both are at the same frequency (note): C 523.25Hz, but the square wave has much more overtones than the sine wave (the sine has no overtones and only one harmonic). Can you notice how the square wave is much more "dirtier" than the sine wave, which is much more "cleaner"?

Using software, we can "see" these overtones, and the waveform of the sound.

This is the waveform of a sine wave:

sine wave

And here is the overtone content of a sine wave.

sine wave fundamental

Here we can clearly see that the sine wave has only one harmonic, the fundamental, and has no overtones. It's that peak at around 523Hz.

Now let's see the waveform of a square wave:

square wave

And the overtones of the square wave:

square wave overtones

The square wave has many more overtones! It sounds "dirtier".

We know that the frequency of the overtones and their relation to the fundamental can also carve how dirty a sound is perceived, it's not all about the quantity.

Here we have a sound with a fundamental frequency of 500 Hz and its first 4 harmonics at 1000, 1500, 2000, and 2500 Hz, and each overtone with an amplitude of 1/n. These are integer multiples of the fundamental.

And here we have a similar sound with a fundamental of 500 Hz, with its first 4 overtones, and each overtone with an amplitude of 1/n. The only difference is that the frequency of the overtones was slightly modified. The new overtone frequencies are: 995, 1515, 2020, and 2450 Hz, they are no longer integer multiples of the fundamental.

The first sounds cleaner than the second because in the first all the overtones are harmonics, all overtones are integer multiples of the fundamental. In contrast, none of the overtones of the second sound are integer multiples of the fundamental, which translates to a dirtier sound.

Making some dirt

We can hear and see how a "clean" sound becomes "dirtier" by adding each overtone individually over time.

This is a sine wave (clean sound) turning into a square wave (dirty sound) over the period of 20 seconds, same note C 523.25Hz (WARNING, the loudness at the end is significantly higher than at the start, be careful with your local sound levels!):

Notice how the sound becomes dirtier as we add more overtones, as the sound turns from a sine wave into a square wave?

Here we can see how overtones are being added over time. From top to bottom is: at 0, 5, 10, 15, and 20 seconds:

0 seconds 5 seconds 10 seconds 15 seconds 20 seconds

Dirty and acoustic

This difference in overtones can be found in acoustic instruments too. Let's look at the overtones of 3 instruments: a clarinet, a piano, and a trumpet, all played in C 261.62Hz.

Clarinet:

Clarinet

Piano:

Piano

Trumpet:

Trumpet

We can see that the trumpet is much more rich in overtone content than the clarinet and the piano; the trumpet is "dirtier".

share|improve this answer
1  
@ JCP - a very interesting answer. Could you give examples of ordinary acoustic instruments which would be deemed to have 'clean' or 'dirty' sounds naturally, using these criteria ? I'd hazard that a clarinet would be quite clean, for example. –  Tim Dec 24 '13 at 14:31
1  
@Tim Added a new section "Dirty and acoustic" that dives a little into acoustic harmonic content. –  JCPedroza Dec 24 '13 at 17:30
1  
@JCP: I believe you've got the alto sax graph in place of the clarinet. (The clarinet, by construction, only has odd numbered harmonics. From the clarinet graph in the link, I guess that is not entirely true though; at least not for C 261.62 Hz where the 4th, 6th, 8th etc harmonics are present in the graph.) –  Ulf Åkerstedt Dec 24 '13 at 22:46
    
@UlfÅkerstedt Good catch! I'll edit the mistake. Seems that the clarinet does produce odd harmonics, but in lower amplitude. –  JCPedroza Dec 24 '13 at 22:50
    
@JCPedroza what software do you use to generate the signals and also get the frequency domain plots? I've seen similar spectrum plots on your other answers. I know it can be done in MATLAB but it isn't anywhere near as pretty. –  Charles Oct 15 '14 at 5:09

It's similar to 'dirty' and 'clean' as far as electric guitar sounds go. A 'clean' sound will be pure in that there are no effects used - in particular overdrive, distortion or even 'crunch'. When , in the old days, valve amps were turned up to 10 (or 11 !!), the sound became distorted. Soon this became the 'I want' sound for guitarists. Thankfully, now, amp. manufacturers can emulate that sort of sound without the players upsetting parents, neighbours, dogs, etc.

It was also used on organ sounds - Spencer Davis Group for one used it on hits. Not too popular for bass guitar players in mainstream, but it works really well with synth bass sound.

So, simple answer - overdriven synth bass sounds.

share|improve this answer

A "clean" sound is close to a pure tone, with maybe some harmonics, like you get from a real instrument being played well.

A "dirty" sound means that you can hear other tones or noise alongside the note itself. It might sound "crunchy" like an overdriven electric guitar with lots of feedback, or "farty" like a wind instrument being overblown.

share|improve this answer

'Dirty' typically means harsh in some way. In an electronic context, this could be by putting a signal through some non-linear distortion (like a typical distorted electrical guitar) that will generate sum and difference harmonics, or by using a process like FM or ring modulation that can produce harmonics that are not integer ratios of the fundamental. In an acoustic context you could produce dirt by setting up an instrument to produce more enharmonic noise - e.g. by having a very low string action on an acoustic guitar.

Although making a sound dirty will often involve introducing more harmonic partials, it's not true to say that a sound with more harmonics is always 'dirtier' than a sound with fewer harmonics. If a sound has many harmonics but they are all integer multiples of the fundamental, the sound may be perceived as just 'bright', rather than dirty.

share|improve this answer

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.