Take the 2-minute tour ×
Music: Practice & Theory Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for musicians, students, and enthusiasts. It's 100% free, no registration required.

For the past couple of years, I've adopted the following approach for fingerpicking folk rock/alternative music...

E - pinky finger

B - ring finger

G - middle finger

D - index finger

A - thumb

E - thumb

At this point, I'm super comfortable with using my pinky finger on the E. I personally think that it is the most ergonomic approach since I don't have to move my ring finger to reach the E (although I have to cover two strings with my thumb). I've started reading that the pinky is rarely used in picking. What are the pros/cons to this approach and should I forgo using the pinky in fingerpicking?

share|improve this question
    
I liked all the answers, as it confirmed to me that using the pinky finger is fine. Thanks for all of the responses! –  jason328 Feb 16 at 2:59

4 Answers 4

up vote 3 down vote accepted

As long as you feel comfortable with your pinky in the E string it's ok. As for advantages, you might find it easier to play arpeggios of 5 and 6 strings (since you have almost all strings covered), or as well play different melodies along the strings at the same time. It is not anything you couldn't do with the common finger position on the strings, but it's all a matter of how comfortable you feel. In the list of disadvantages you should consider the fact that the pinky finger is the weakest finger, and it might make a difference on your E string picking strength and/or precision. But again, it all depends on your own preferences. Who knows, maybe you can go further with it and create a new technique! Hope that helps, this is my very first answer (:

share|improve this answer

I'm also using my pinky a lot when finger picking. In this way there's not so much difference switching between pure finger picking and hybrid picking. So that's another benefit of this approach. With hybrid picking your index finger is not available, so there it's natural to use the pinky more. Plucking two adjacent strings feels more natural with the middle and ring finger rather than index and middle finger too.

share|improve this answer

Hard and fast rules will only guide you to what people have found worked for them. There is nothing wrong with changing to suit yourself. The thumb sounds good on the lowest two strings, as that's where the bass line often runs, so a fleshy sound is appropriate.A pattern I sometimes use involves only the top four strings, so I use thumb on 4 and 3, with top two strings being played with m and a usually.The pinky can and should be used - it's waiting for the opportunity ! Yes, it may be a bit weak, but soon it catches up with the others, given that chance.Playing a chord on top four, plucking simultaneously, can ONLY be achieved with all four fingers. Keep going, it's the end product that's more important than how you physically produce it.

share|improve this answer

If you feel comfortable playing with your little finger, congratulations. You have the advantage. There's absolutely nothing wrong with it. After all, you use your (probably even weaker) left hand pinkie too. And pianists use their every finger.

Most classical guitarists play only with their four or even three first fingers because they find using their whole hand too hard. Basically there's two reasons for that:

  1. Many players hold their plucking hand in a position where it is hard for little finger to reach the strings. Especially if it is relatively short compared to other fingers.
  2. Classical players play mostly without amplification and find it easier to get a loud and fat sound with their strongest fingers.

Years ago I asked my teacher about this and he told that actually you can develop a better control for little finger because it has its own moving muscle unlike middle and ring fingers. He is a musician and not a physician so his explanation should probably be taken with a grain of salt.

share|improve this answer

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.