Take the 2-minute tour ×
Music: Practice & Theory Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for musicians, students, and enthusiasts. It's 100% free, no registration required.

Now this question is by no means an attack on any conductor or orchestra, nor Prokofiev himself, but why does it seem that it's hard for everyone to get right into time with one another with this piece? In literally every recording and performance I've heard the timing is off, sometimes just barely, sometimes quite obviously. This video shows what I'm getting at, and particularly shows how the different registers of the brass section seem to be out of time with one another. Still, once everything gets going things click together, which leads me to believe it's just tricky timing. I'd really like a more professional answer beyond my own speculation.

share|improve this question
1  
I couldn't hear anything off in that video. It just sounded syncopated to me. –  Bradd Szonye May 14 at 9:41
    
Does syncopated mean deliberately off? It sounds like they start too fast compared to: youtube.com/watch?v=ljOMXgfflRI, and there could be something odd right at the start, but it seemed to go away after a few listens. Perhaps it's just the tempo that sounds wrong I'm used to listening to a slower version. –  Lee Kowalkowski May 14 at 10:38
1  
I've got a couple recordings of this ballet, and don't hear what you hear. The score is very straightforward: nothing more than dotted-eighth ; sixteenth note pairings plus a "rhythm bass". I fear this may be your ear hearing things that aren't there. –  Carl Witthoft May 14 at 11:50
1  
I must say, Gergiev isn't doing very well. His hands are severely shaking and some parts he falls behind. This may have caused the rather clumsy beginning. –  11684 May 15 at 13:33
1  
Well, @FélixGagnon-Grenier, you might ask why they're so clumsy! I'm sure those knights know how to party –  player3 Jun 14 at 14:38

2 Answers 2

up vote 2 down vote accepted

The score is here imslp.org/wiki/Special:ImagefromIndex/35364 The dance is at page 145 (131 in the pdf)

"the different registers of the brass section seem to be out of time with one another."

Low brass (f.e. tubas) tends to get the 1 and 3; higher brass (f.e. cornet) gets the 2 and 4 "afterbeat". This is in iteself not special or odd.

When I hear this piece, also in the recording you posted, I can simply count 1, 2, 3, 4, and the low brass is on 1 and 3. Does that work for you?

What might be putting you off is that in this recording, the first 2 beats start off a bit slower then the remainder. Perhaps the expectation of a slower tempo unsettles you?

share|improve this answer

You are right. The low brass (at beats 1 and 3) seems to start at a tempo that is slightly faster than the low strings that should answer at beats 2 and 4. It's sounds more like the strings answer at "2-and" and "4-and" in the first measure. They are a bit closer at second measure, and when the rest come in third measure, everything is on track. I think part of the problem is that the conductor "jumps in" when starting without any indication of the tempo.

share|improve this answer
    
I appreciate the input! Thanks for explaining what Gergiev himself was doing that made the timing rocky at the beginning. –  player3 May 16 at 17:45

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.