Take the 2-minute tour ×
Musical Practice & Performance Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for musicians, students, and enthusiasts. It's 100% free, no registration required.

I was reading 10 minute guitar workout and I'm doing some exercises to understand how to create a Cmaj6 chord for example, from a C major chord.

When I was reading online for tabs to understand which notes were the 4th, the 6th note etc from the C major octave I stumbled upon two websites with two different tabs for the first octave, although the notes are the same which makes both of them correct I assume:

http://www.guitarcommand.com/c-major-scale-guitar/

http://www.studybass.com/lessons/bass-scales/one-octave-major-scale/

The second scale sounds better to me for the D note, since I prefer it played on the E string 5th chord than open on the D string.

Could you tell me why I see different tabs? Is there a source you recommend for me to use a reference for this kind of exercise where I can see the notes a major scale is composed of?

Thank you in advance.

share|improve this question
    
Do you mean 'the D note sounds better on the fifth FRET of the 5th STRING' ? –  Tim Jun 6 at 15:40

2 Answers 2

up vote 5 down vote accepted

The first one is the "c-major scale in open position" -- note how it uses open strings. The fingering used for this scale is tied to that specific position on the fretboard.

The second one is the "c-major scale at the third fret" -- note that all notes are fretted. This scale pattern can be moved up or down the neck to play different major scales.

In some respect the movable scales are more useful since you can use the same patterns at different locations up/down the neck to play in different keys, but you'll want to learn the open position scales too. (for some people learning the open position scales is easier since the nut is an extra "finger" that helps you).

share|improve this answer
    
Also note that one's from a "studybass.com" while the other's from "guitarcommand.com". Even if you took the open position and moved it, it has more for the third and fourth fingers to do which may be more difficult on a bass. –  Joshua Taylor Jun 6 at 20:57

As Dave states, the first is an open Cmaj scale, using as many open strings as possible. The second is actually on a bass, so there is no direct comparison.They are not in the same octave. However, if you pretended that those 4 strings were the bottom 4 on your guitar, then you could use the same positions as shown, and actually play the scale an octave higher than on bass. It will sound the same as the first one, but with all notes 'closed'. This can be moved up and down to produce many other major scales of one octave. Move the pattern up two frets, and you're in Dmaj. Up two more and it's Emaj. Do try to start playing the notes with your middle finger, and use the 'one finger per fret' trick. Your whole hand will encompass all the notes without moving up or down.

There are numerous different patterns for each scale, it's the way the guitar is configured. It is a mixed blessing, in that it can simplify changing to a different key, but seems complex because there are several patterns to learn which all give you the same end product - a scale. In other words, there are multiple places to play the exact same note. Only two for that low C (5th string 3rd fret and low E 8th fret).But get up to higher notes, like top E - top string open, 2nd string 5th fret, 3rd string 9th fret, 4th string 14th fret, 5th string 19th fret 6th string 24th fret - and that's without looking at another 5 harmonics !!So scales can be played wherever the set of notes can be found. Tricky.

share|improve this answer

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.