Take the 2-minute tour ×
Music: Practice & Theory Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for musicians, students, and enthusiasts. It's 100% free, no registration required.

I'm interested in playing around with a musical saw, like the theme from One Flew Over The Cuckoo's Nest.

Looking around and watching a few tutorial videos, it looks like a very easy instrument to pick up and play; it seems like you don't need anywhere near the bow control that you need for a decent violin sound.

I'm concerned that a) it will be difficult to control the pitch you're playing at, and b) that it's harder than it looks to get the bowing right (I don't play a string instrument)

so, what are some of the technical issues I should consider, and how easy is the musical saw, as an instrument, to play?

share|improve this question

2 Answers 2

up vote 10 down vote accepted

I own a musical saw. I have found it very difficult to get started, and gave up before being able to play a simple tune with any kind of fluency.

The first challenge is to coax a clean note out of the saw. You must bend the saw into an 'S' shape, and bow at the resonant position. If you bow in the wrong place, you'll get an ugly scrape. If you bow in just the right place, you'll get the pure ringing saw sound you're used to. There is a right amount of pressure - too light and the sound will be thin. Too heavy and the sound will be dull.

Many people use a "cheat" to make forming the 'S' shape easier - this is a wooden handle with a slot into which the end of the saw fits. It just gives you some leverage instead of having to hold the end in a tiring, vice-like grip.

Then, when you change the depth of the 'S' to change the pitch, the resonant position changes, so you have to bow in a different place. To play fluently, you need to constantly move the bowing position to correspond to the pitch.

On top of that, as you've already noted, you have to intonate by ear - which may or may not be a challenge for you.

Perhaps with one-to-one instruction it would be easier. I think with a teacher telling me how much pressure to apply to the bow, how much rosin to put on, and so forth, I might have got further.

I still believe it would be an extremely satisfying skill to gain.

share|improve this answer

Easy to learn to make noise with, difficult to learn to play well. Perhaps this is why there aren't that many sawists... The NYC Musical Saw Festival has workshops included in the festival's price of $10. Probably the best deal www.MusicalSawFestival.org Private lessons available also. The type of saw you get also can greatly help speed up the learning process. I suggest you e-mail your questions through the festival's 'Contact' page.

share|improve this answer

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.