Take the 2-minute tour ×
Musical Practice & Performance Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for musicians, students, and enthusiasts. It's 100% free, no registration required.

For example, when I watch Eric Clapton live, playing his acoustic guitar, he uses jack output and a mic.

there

Why is it? Is it for acoustic nuance?

share|improve this question

4 Answers 4

up vote 22 down vote accepted

As others have noted, the properties of the signal from the microphone and from the piezo pickup will be different. The microphone picks up the same kind of air vibrations your ear does. The piezo pickup picks up the vibration of the saddle.

The pickup has the advantage of being less susceptible to (but not immune to) feedback, and it moves with the guitar.

The microphone has the advantage of getting a more natural sound, but several practical disadvantages such as:

  • picking up extraneous sounds
  • not hearing the instrument if it moves away from where the mic is pointing
  • high susceptibility to feedback

If, as a sound engineer, you have both signals, you give yourself a range of options:

  • You can mix both signals to produce a tone you like
  • You can use the mic alone as "Plan A", and fade to the pickup if any of the mic's disadvantages come into play (e.g. the performer moves away from the mic; feedback becomes a problem; etc.)
  • You can use the pickup signal for PA, while recording the mic for the concert album.
  • You can use the pickup signal for stage monitors, while feeding the mic signal to the PA - avoiding feedback but giving the audience the more natural sound
share|improve this answer

The sound from a microphone inside the guitar (or piezo pickups as in the case with Clapton) is different from the sound outside of the guitar. The signal from internal microphones or pickups will be more consistent, since it is not affected by movements of the guitar. Likely the signals are mixed to get the best of both worlds.

share|improve this answer
1  
Eric Clapton uses under saddle piezo pickups, not an internal mic pickup. Specifically the Carlos Juan CP1. –  Fergus Jul 9 at 8:41
1  
@Fergus: Then it's even more difference in sound. Thanks for the info. –  Meaningful Username Jul 9 at 8:41

Adding to Meaningful Username's answer, the different sources (piezo pickup vs microphone) emphasise different parts of the guitar's sound. Not only is it used to help the sound be more consistent etc. but the different sounds themselves make for much more versatility when mixing.

In general (this can vary wildly) a microphone will give a more "natural" sound (ie. closer to what we perceive when listening to it un-amplified) and can be described as "full sounding". Of course this depends on the microphone and placement. The pickup will often give a much more "up front" sound, emphasising the mid range more than our ears do. By itself sometimes it can sound a little thin but can really make the sound stand out when mixed with the microphone source.

As mentioned, this is definitely prone to variations. Some pickups have enormous frequency range and some microphones are very thin or up-front sounding.

share|improve this answer

The sound from the microphone is undoubtedly the best, if you want the music to sound as close as you can to how it sounds unamplified. The mic captures all of the natural resonances of the guitar without the "quack" of a piezo pickup.

However, controlling feedback with only a microphone is difficult. The musician will have to keep their guitar relatively still while playing. Blending the microphone sound with sound from a piezo pickup helps to mitigate these issues.

Some artists (for example, Gillian Welch and David Rawlings) exclusively use microphones for their guitars. However as you add more band members, this becomes more and more difficult to set up! This excerpt here is from an interview in the April 1999 issue of the Acoustic Guitar Magazine.

Unless the artist is fanatically dedicated to the sound quality of their performance, they'll add a pickup to make set-up easier.

share|improve this answer

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.