Music: Practice & Theory Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for musicians, students, and enthusiasts. Join them; it only takes a minute:

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

The method of transposing riffs to fit the chord changes makes all bluegrass solos sound the same. Bluegrass players such as Doc Watson and Tony Rice appear to transcend this cliche.

What techniques do they employ to do this, and are there other techniques and musicians like them?

share|improve this question
up vote 3 down vote accepted

That's the big question, isn't it! I don't know of any techniques in the formal sense but I do have some thoughts that might help. I really don't know what level you are so I may not be of much help - I'm just thinking out loud here.

For starters, they play the melody and then play around the melody. Doc cut his teeth on fiddle tunes and knows the melody to tons of them. Even if you don't know the melody of a specific tune, if you have a large arsenal of melodies at your disposal you can cut and paste with nearly endless possibilities.

Thinking in terms of a melodic phrase (try to ask a question and then answer it) can do a lot to keep things fresh.

When you learn a lick, learn to play around with it - tony can be very licky but he also knows how to mess with it. The trick is to not have a lick set in stone but rather to know what the lick sounds like, learn what parts of the lick give which sound, and then practice rearranging it.

Really utilize different parts of the neck and find ways to transition between them. This isn't AS big in bluegrass as it is with other styles (I swear, we capo everything for the TONE! ) but it's still pretty big and it can add a whole dimension to your playing.

Listen to the guys Tony and Doc listened to. Find out their inspirations!

Try to play like a fiddle player - if I have my history right, Doc started flat picking to fill in for a fiddle player at a dance. From the get-go he was trying to sound like a fiddle player.

Play the G run ALL the time!!! Just kidding ;)

Really though it's all about melodic playing. Great players let the song speak for itself and try not to get in the way of the music.

Also are you up on Norman Blake?

share|improve this answer

They not-so-simply dress it up with more musical knowledge. When the tune is a simple and typical bluegrass G-C-D-G (1-4-5-1) chord progression:

On the simplest level, they inherently know that the G7 leads into the C in a pleasantly melodic way, and the D7 leads back to the root. However the the G7 does not lead to D and the C7 does not lead back to G. Then they can combine that into melodic runs and such, working around the basic theme.

Going a bit further, they know when a C6 will sound good. They know when the C6 will not quite fit the personality of the tune (the sixth tends to lend a jazzy/swingy feel).

Diminished chords. Blue notes. Both minor ascending and minor descending scales. Ornaments, bends, and emphasis. It's all familiarity with the fingerboard, the style, and the expression = Experience. The names you list are kings of the genre, and that's exactly why they transcend the genre and are the kings. Now go learn to play some of their riffs: Imitation is the highest form of flattery, and a great way to learn more about your music.

share|improve this answer

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.