Take the 2-minute tour ×
Musical Practice & Performance Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for musicians, students, and enthusiasts. It's 100% free, no registration required.

I'm looking for a MIDI keyboard with integrated audio interface so I can play without plugging in to the computer. There were few products like M-Audio ProKeys and M-Audio Keystation 49i but these products are discontinued.

Is there any reason why they were discontinued? Are there any other products available now?

Thanks :)

share|improve this question
2  
Do you want a keyboard that can act both as a MIDI input device and also synth on itself? If so, you can use any digital piano, e. g. Yamaha P-105 –  Mischa Arefiev Aug 17 at 20:17
    
@MischaArefiev The ProKeys does not have an audio interface, so what is meant is a synthesizer. –  CL. Aug 17 at 20:23
    
@CL. ProKeys Sono 61 and 88 does have built in audio (about 10 instruments), and I'm basically looking for a MIDI keyboard not a synthesizer. –  flopr Aug 17 at 21:56
    
@flopr: The Sono 61 and 88 actually have built in 128 General MIDI range of instruments plus 46 drum sounds. The 5 or 10 high quality instruments have dedicated buttons but you can access the others. The Sonos incorporate MIDI-keyboard, sound synthesis and a basic audio mixer (e.g. for guitar and mic). You only need external monitors. As in CLs answer, stage-piano is a useful term for this class of devices. –  RedGrittyBrick Aug 17 at 23:59
    
There's an enormous range of integrated keyboard synthesizers; what's your budget? What range of sounds do you need? Do you need sequencing capability on the keyboard itself? –  Russell Borogove Aug 18 at 0:37

2 Answers 2

Except at the "toy" end of the market, almost any synthesiser or electric piano you can buy today will have MIDI in and out.

Reading between the lines, I suppose the challenge you have is that you want a good keyboard, with budget sounds. That may be difficult to find.

I would recommend shopping around and basing your shortlist on the mechanical aspects of the instrument -- if you want it to feel like a piano, look at digital pianos; if you want it to feel like an organ, look at more "synthy" keyboards.

Then ensure that MIDI in and out is supported. Just for futureproofing, you should check:

  • that you can use the keyboard to control other sound modules.
  • that you can control the sound module from another MIDI source (like a sequencer)

It's an unusual keyboard that doesn't meet these requirements -- but you should check just in case.

... and finally, when you are trying out the instruments in the shop, use the sounds it makes as a deciding criterion.

share|improve this answer

Only M-Audio knows why they were discontinued. (I'd guess that they were not able to keep updating their drivers, which were needed because they were using a non-standard protocol.)

There are many MIDI keyboards with integrated synthesizer; they are called stage pianos.

share|improve this answer
    
From what I recall, the special drivers were for low-latency. In situations where latency was not an issue, you can use standard USB-MIDI drivers. –  RedGrittyBrick Aug 18 at 0:06
    
In my world, there are many MIDI keyboards with integrated synthesizer; they're called synthesizers or keyboard synthesizers. –  Russell Borogove Aug 18 at 0:36
    
@RedGrittyBrick The protocol itself has exactly the same latency as that defined in the USB audio specification. Early Windows drivers were inefficient; the M-Audio protocol is deliberately incompatible to prevent the Windows driver from being used, and it's not possible to use the standard driver with those M-Audio devices. Later M-Audio devices are using the standard protocol. (Roland built some devices where you could choose between standard and custom drivers.) –  CL. Aug 18 at 7:17

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.