Take the 2-minute tour ×
Musical Practice & Performance Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for musicians, students, and enthusiasts. It's 100% free, no registration required.

This is the first movement of sonata in G Major Hob. XVI: 8 by Haydn:

enter image description here

In bars 6, 8 and 12 there are trills (presumably in 8), but each one is represented a little bit differently. In bar 6 there are the trill sign and square brackets to indicate the adjacent note to trill with, in bar 8 only the square brackets, and in bar 12 only the trill.

Is there a reason for the difference in notation? are all three played the same?

share|improve this question
add comment

2 Answers

up vote 4 down vote accepted

These are in fact all different. The D and G and bars 6 and 8 are in square brackets by the editor to indicate that they should be re-attacked, since the preceding note is the same. Bar 8 is not a trill. It should be played as two eighth notes G and F. Bar 12 is a normal trill where its first note (F#) was not the last one played, so no need to indicate it with square brackets.

I would also recommend listening to a recording.

share|improve this answer
    
Do you mean that the first two are appoggiaturas? –  American Luke Aug 21 '12 at 19:08
    
Bar 8 is, yes. Bar 6 is a normal trill. –  mjibson Aug 21 '12 at 20:27
    
I don't know. None of the other trills tell which note to trill with, and there's nothing out of the ordinary with trilling C with D there. I think bar 6 is an appoggiatura and then a trill. –  American Luke Aug 22 '12 at 1:30
    
This manuscript writes out the appoggiatura in bar 8 and specifies trills in bars 6 and 12. The linked recording in my answer is the same. –  mjibson Aug 22 '12 at 1:35
    
You're right. I should have checked the original piece. It appears that bar 13 is actually a trill and turn. –  American Luke Aug 22 '12 at 1:58
add comment

Are you familiar with the concepts of "early music" and "historically-informed performance"?

General background rather than a specific answer: I'm not a keyboardist or instrumentalist, but I work as a volunteer business person with a Baroque orchestra composed of career specialists in early music and historically-informed performance. All I can say is that the subject of how to correctly play ornaments and trills in Baroque and Classical music is a subject that's had an explosive amount of study done on it in recent decades.

Look for resources in "early music" and "historically-informed performance" (what we used to call "authentic performance practice" although that term has fallen out of favor), and by all means listen to recordings that you know to be made by early music specialists on period instruments (harpsichord and early fortepiano) and not by "modern-style" pianists playing on "modern" pianos.

The other element, of course, is that there is room for personal interpretation and a little improvisation in places when you perform these pieces. But how much liberty to take with the material is a subject of endless debate and must just come down to your musical knowledge and taste.

share|improve this answer
add comment

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.