Reputation
21,732
Next tag badge:
96/100 score
22/20 answers
Badges
2 39 91
Newest
 Enlightened
Impact
~1.1m people reached

12h
comment What does it mean to play a note for half a second?
Your car travels at 60 miles per hour. You drive it for 1/2 of one hour. Do you mean to tell me that the car has not traveled any distance at all, because it failed to travel for a full hour? Of course not. Your car has traveled 30 miles. Similarly, your note vibrates at the rate of 440 vibrations per second. You play the note for 1/2 second. Do you mean to tell me that your note made no sound? Of course not. Your note made a sound for 0.5 seconds. I think your problem is that you do not understand maths.
2d
comment Are there any plain nylon bass strings for classical guitar?
Flat-wound? No. But I like the D'Addario EXP round-wound coated strings, which are designed to last longer because the polymer coating keeps the dirt and oils from the fingers from getting to the metal windings. As a side-benefit, they are less "squeaky". goo.gl/jFrboM
Apr
18
comment Why are time signatures needed?
It is often said by a rock music arranger trying to get symphony orchestra players to accompany a rock band: "You can notate the notes in sheet music, but you cannot notate the feel." Playing the feel of a phrase depends on the time signature together with knowing the correct style of a piece of music and which beats to emphasize, push or pull, which notes to play full value and which to shorten slightly, and the precise points at which musicians should breathe, in unison or staggered. These things can never be derived, totally, by just looking at the duration of each of the notes.
Apr
18
comment Why are time signatures needed?
I stand by my answer. I am making the essential distinction between the notation of the notes' values on the one hand and the phrasing or feel of a measure or passage or phrase on the other. This distinction is subtle yet vital to musicianship, but a difficult concept to explain to a beginner. And as for a large ensemble playing in rhythmic unison with a certain feel, it does indeed happen all the time, but it takes experienced musicians and a conductor to do it correctly.
Apr
5
comment Enquiry to Male Passaggio and Vocal production in classical music
Yes, F is usually the "break point" or passagio for a tenor. I'm not sure what it is you wish to ask. Can you clarify your question?
Apr
4
comment Which source for Scarlatti K208? Can I mix and match versions?
And with music from Scarlatti's time, you were expected to improvise a bit when you performed a written piece. Although, today, the questions of how to improvise and how much are the subjects of endless debate.
Apr
4
comment Which source for Scarlatti K208? Can I mix and match versions?
OK, so the point is that this is a certain published edition of a very old composition, and the editor of this edition has chosen to include notes about how different historical editions of this piece of music, over the centuries, contained alternate notes in different passages. You, the performer, have to decide which way you want to play it when there are alternatives presented. Have I got that right?
Apr
1
comment I have Finale and I am having trouble
Have you read the Finale owners' manual? It contains a section on how to set it up for transcribing what you play.
Apr
1
comment Is there a proper way to train the ears?
"Ear Training" is a subject taught in music schools and universities. It is usually taught as a component of music theory in a 2-year curriculum. There are textbooks and lesson plans and software programs for ear training.
Apr
1
comment Why is Hendrix's tuning at Woodstock in between Eb and E?
What makes you think that when the band went on stage that they were concerned about being exactly in tune according to some external standard? As long as they were in tune with each other, they did not care about anything else. It is the same with all bands everywhere, all the time. Furthermore in the 1960s there were no tuning devices for use in live performance other than a metal tuning fork and the performers' ears.
Apr
1
comment I have Finale and I am having trouble
The Finale company has a user support forum. You should post your questions there. There are many experts there that could help you. forum.makemusic.com
Mar
30
comment How can I produce any melody on my guitar as effortlessly as I do with my voice?
Practice, practice, practice. First "hear" the melody inside your head. Then sing the melody out loud. Then sing along with the melody as you are picking each note on the guitar. Listen to jazz guitarist George Benson and rock bassist Oteil Burbridge -- they do this all the time.
Mar
22
comment How are intervals defined and measured?
In addition to understanding what intervals are, you will also want to understand the concept of the scale degree of each chord in a given key, the quality of the chord that goes with each scale degree, and how certain chord progressions work with regard to the concepts of resolution and cadence.
Mar
22
comment Looking at the fretboard is ruining my stage presence
Practice playing while looking yourself in the eye in a mirror. Then practice playing while recording video of yourself on your cell phone, while looking straight at the lens. Play back the video and confirm that you don't look away from the lens. When you get on stage, find a place in the audience where you can look and try to keep eye contact with people (if the stage lighting permits this).
Mar
16
comment I want to learn to play a specific song on the piano
I think this would be worth a try! But it will have to be a patient, committed try.
Mar
15
comment I want to learn to play a specific song on the piano
Playing an instrument in public for the first time is something that causes stress and anxiety. If you attempt this at your father's memorial service, you may also be overcome with emotion, and it is not possible to play an instrument well if you are overcome with emotion. I applaud your desire to honor your father, but I believe you would be setting yourself up for a terrible time of stress and anxiety if you play piano at his memorial service. I suggest you find some other way to honor him on that day.
Mar
14
comment How can I make a note repeat endlessly when I hold down a key in Garageband?
No, you misunderstand the use of the term. The term "virtual instrument" refers to all computer apps that can be played like a musical instrument, regardless of their platform or format. "Audio Unit" or AU, is the name of Apple's plug-in architecture. Other plug-in formats include VST (Steinberg) and RTAS (Avid Pro Tools). So virtual instruments may be stand-alone apps, and/or plug-ins in VST or AU or RTAS or many other formats. And many virtual instrument apps are available from their creator in multiple plug-in formats.
Mar
13
comment How do I train myself to sing pure vowels?
Trust me. Being a native speaker of English makes it extremely hard to learn to voice the five pure vowels (as in Latin, Spanish and Italian) consistently. English has about 16 vowel sounds, and we English speakers find it very hard to banish our dipthongs and extraneous vowels from our myriad regional English accents when we sing certain other languages.
Mar
4
comment Confusion about major and minor second intervals
Have you actually played a major scale or a minor scale on an instrument yourself, or are you just reading about scales on a website or in a book ? If you would actually play a few scales on your instrument, you would hear the distinction and you would answer your own question.
Feb
19
comment Traveling or moving neck bow
Contact the Godin company customer service department and ask about authorized repair work and whether or not it is covered by their warranty.