773 reputation
37
bio website nats-www.informatik.uni-hambu…
location Hamburg, Germany
age 42
visits member for 2 years, 3 months
seen 27 mins ago

9h
comment Do we find music arranged according to Western Music Theory pleasing because of “biological instinct” or because of what we learn?
@RockinCowboy "wrongly convincing". Asking whether something is "due to instinct" or "due to learning" implies that either one or the other is the case, but in fact almost certainly both mechanisms are operating. People are quite bad at understanding mixed-causality situations, which is why there are so many "false dichotomies". Arguments based on these are usually specious :)
1d
comment Do we find music arranged according to Western Music Theory pleasing because of “biological instinct” or because of what we learn?
The alternative is specious. A huge part of what we transmit to our children culturally is also biologically constrained (but not determined). There are many different scales that peoples consider "natural", but only a tiny fraction of those that would be mathematically possible actually occur. Most of them would be hard-pressed to be accepted by any culture.
Jan
25
answered Is it possible to do tempo changes while practicing with metronome?
Jan
21
comment What's the term for speaking fast in a verse
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Patter_song
Jan
21
comment Where to upload (keyboard) transcriptions?
The standard resource is imslp.org. Do you have a particular reason why you think they would not want your scores? There is no particular notability requirement - I've even uploaded myself and nobody objects.
Jan
6
comment How do you play a glissando with two notes?
With great difficulty! I dare anyone to practice this for some time and not sustain at least slight skin injuries. It's still a fun piece to play, though.
Dec
21
comment Good jazz pianists to transcribe for a beginner
Didier Squiban - provided you accept his music as 'Jazz' at all.
Dec
19
comment Does the line between the time signature have a name?
How would one know? They're always printed centered so that there already is a line there anyway.
Dec
10
comment How does your brain learn to play the piano two-handed?
He he. Try learning drums, or the pipe organ - it's like this, only 50% harder. No worries, you will get there; it requires a lot of tedious practice that seems to achieve nothing, but actually does.
Nov
18
comment Is there a standard notation for piano fingering?
There's still 'sopra' or 'sotto', indicating how to position your hands relative to each other when they interfere with each other. Rarely necessary, but can be a bit of an eye-opener when used judiciously.
Nov
15
comment Why do I need to learn counterpoint if I know harmony?
This is a lot like asking "I want to learn Spanish, do I really need vowels? Aren't consonants enough to get by?"
Nov
14
answered Bartok - Mikrokosmos - Book 1 - 10 “With alternate hands”: Thumb on a black key?
Nov
13
answered Why is greensleeves considered to be in sextuple meter?
Oct
27
awarded  Commentator
Oct
23
awarded  Yearling
Sep
23
answered What does a piano teacher do?
Aug
9
comment What made Mozart unique as an improviser?
There is little information about that, since there are no recordings, and the few contemporary descriptions are hard to interpret in modern terms. For what it's worth, Wolfgang Hildesheimer assumes that KV397 is one of Mozart's improvisations, and that he would have improvised countless similar pieces, which happened not to get transcribed.
Aug
9
comment Does following “musical forms” suppress “creativity”?
Note that the "free fantasia" is itself a respected musical form - musicians of all ages have occasionally felt the need to break fundamental rules without starting a whole musical revolution about it. That's why such a paradoxical "catch-all" genre exists.
Jul
31
comment How do instruments with discrete tuning play chords alongside those with continuous tuning?
Almost all fixed-pitch instruments in the orchestra (harps, xylophones, piano) don't produce sustained notes, which makes the difference even less noticeable. The one exception is the rarely-used pipe organ, and you do in fact often hear discrepancies with a prominent organ part if you listen closely.
Jul
30
answered Tied Db in Liszt's Consolation No. 3