Skip to main content
added 182 characters in body
Source Link
Old Brixtonian
  • 5.5k
  • 13
  • 24

The G minor version has fewer mistakes than the other versions, which have been prepared by someone with little skill in music or in notation software.:

enter image description here

It's hard to tell which version came first, but on a violin the G minor version will obviously sound richer and more resonant than the G#m version: more resonant, the string-lengths being greater than if you play it a semitone higher.

Have you got an accompaniment for the G minor version? It is rather short of expression markings, isn't it? But what bowing there is is OK. Bar seven is wrongly notated: the tied A's should just be a regular quaver.

The G minor version has fewer mistakes than the other versions, which have been prepared by someone with little skill in music or in notation software. It's hard to tell which version came first, but on a violin the G minor version will sound richer than the G#m version: more resonant.

Have you got an accompaniment for the G minor version? It is rather short of expression markings, isn't it? But what bowing there is OK. Bar seven is wrongly notated: the tied A's should just be a regular quaver.

The G minor version has fewer mistakes than the other versions, which have been prepared by someone with little skill in music or in notation software:

enter image description here

It's hard to tell which version came first, but on a violin the G minor version will obviously sound richer and more resonant than the G#m version, the string-lengths being greater than if you play it a semitone higher.

Have you got an accompaniment for the G minor version? It is rather short of expression markings, isn't it? But what bowing there is is OK. Bar seven is wrongly notated: the tied A's should just be a regular quaver.

Source Link
Old Brixtonian
  • 5.5k
  • 13
  • 24

The G minor version has fewer mistakes than the other versions, which have been prepared by someone with little skill in music or in notation software. It's hard to tell which version came first, but on a violin the G minor version will sound richer than the G#m version: more resonant.

Have you got an accompaniment for the G minor version? It is rather short of expression markings, isn't it? But what bowing there is OK. Bar seven is wrongly notated: the tied A's should just be a regular quaver.