Skip to main content
added 1674 characters in body
Source Link
Michael Curtis
  • 59.5k
  • 4
  • 51
  • 164

Your question seems to telegraph the expected answer: the teaching is focused on recitals and advancing through graded methods. That kind of teaching isn't concerned with understanding why things happen in music.


EDIT

I wasn't going to add this initially, but there seems to be a lot of interest (disagreement) on this topic of transposing.

Recently I started working on Bach's Two Part Invention in C Minor and I simply did not want to memorize it. I've done that before with other music, and eventually I forget the stuff.

I decided to take most of the expository material and break it up into two beat units which I then practiced by sequencing the stuff up and down by step. I also inverted the parts between the hands. I made myself a sort of shorthand score of what I was doing, like this...

enter image description here

...the double notes at the end of phrases are supposed to show the continuation by sequence up/down. Fingerings above/below are RH/LH depending on how the hands invert. I don't expect anyone else to read this, but I think the basic idea should be clear enough.

Now I've moved on to playing each hands separately, but I play it in various keys. The music itself modulated up a fifth so you can just repeat the exposition and keep going around the circle of fifths. After working through a few keys and getting used to the changing "topographical" feel it seems I can play it in any key comfortably without practice.

I'm not done with the piece yet, and certainly this take more time than just memorizing it in C, but I definitely feel like I'm learn much, much more this way. My hands move more freely and I better understand the actual tonal content of the music.

At the very least, you aren't the only person that thinks transposing is a useful study method.

Your question seems to telegraph the expected answer: the teaching is focused on recitals and advancing through graded methods. That kind of teaching isn't concerned with understanding why things happen in music.

Your question seems to telegraph the expected answer: the teaching is focused on recitals and advancing through graded methods. That kind of teaching isn't concerned with understanding why things happen in music.


EDIT

I wasn't going to add this initially, but there seems to be a lot of interest (disagreement) on this topic of transposing.

Recently I started working on Bach's Two Part Invention in C Minor and I simply did not want to memorize it. I've done that before with other music, and eventually I forget the stuff.

I decided to take most of the expository material and break it up into two beat units which I then practiced by sequencing the stuff up and down by step. I also inverted the parts between the hands. I made myself a sort of shorthand score of what I was doing, like this...

enter image description here

...the double notes at the end of phrases are supposed to show the continuation by sequence up/down. Fingerings above/below are RH/LH depending on how the hands invert. I don't expect anyone else to read this, but I think the basic idea should be clear enough.

Now I've moved on to playing each hands separately, but I play it in various keys. The music itself modulated up a fifth so you can just repeat the exposition and keep going around the circle of fifths. After working through a few keys and getting used to the changing "topographical" feel it seems I can play it in any key comfortably without practice.

I'm not done with the piece yet, and certainly this take more time than just memorizing it in C, but I definitely feel like I'm learn much, much more this way. My hands move more freely and I better understand the actual tonal content of the music.

At the very least, you aren't the only person that thinks transposing is a useful study method.

Source Link
Michael Curtis
  • 59.5k
  • 4
  • 51
  • 164

Your question seems to telegraph the expected answer: the teaching is focused on recitals and advancing through graded methods. That kind of teaching isn't concerned with understanding why things happen in music.