Skip to main content
edited body
Source Link
user62847
user62847

It's even possible to detach notes in one voice of a double stop while continuing a note in the other voice, using a rocking movement of the bow. Cf the Andante in Bach's solo violin sonata 2 with repeated detached notes in the lower voice while a sustained note is sometimes held explicitly in the upper voice.Andante from BWV1003, Solo Sonata 2 for violin by J.S.Bach However, that kind of technique tends to be reserved to solo violin performances as it takes a lot of practice. However, the passage you quote is trivial in thirdfirst position with regard to double stops. You should not expect the tricky detached technique Bach calls for in something intended for a trio, so you should place a slur over the eighths regardless of whether the piano version has them.

It's even possible to detach notes in one voice of a double stop while continuing a note in the other voice, using a rocking movement of the bow. Cf the Andante in Bach's solo violin sonata 2 with repeated detached notes in the lower voice while a sustained note is sometimes held explicitly in the upper voice.Andante from BWV1003, Solo Sonata 2 for violin by J.S.Bach However, that kind of technique tends to be reserved to solo violin performances as it takes a lot of practice. However, the passage you quote is trivial in third position with regard to double stops. You should not expect the tricky detached technique Bach calls for in something intended for a trio, so you should place a slur over the eighths regardless of whether the piano version has them.

It's even possible to detach notes in one voice of a double stop while continuing a note in the other voice, using a rocking movement of the bow. Cf the Andante in Bach's solo violin sonata 2 with repeated detached notes in the lower voice while a sustained note is sometimes held explicitly in the upper voice.Andante from BWV1003, Solo Sonata 2 for violin by J.S.Bach However, that kind of technique tends to be reserved to solo violin performances as it takes a lot of practice. However, the passage you quote is trivial in first position with regard to double stops. You should not expect the tricky detached technique Bach calls for in something intended for a trio, so you should place a slur over the eighths regardless of whether the piano version has them.

Source Link
user62847
user62847

It's even possible to detach notes in one voice of a double stop while continuing a note in the other voice, using a rocking movement of the bow. Cf the Andante in Bach's solo violin sonata 2 with repeated detached notes in the lower voice while a sustained note is sometimes held explicitly in the upper voice.Andante from BWV1003, Solo Sonata 2 for violin by J.S.Bach However, that kind of technique tends to be reserved to solo violin performances as it takes a lot of practice. However, the passage you quote is trivial in third position with regard to double stops. You should not expect the tricky detached technique Bach calls for in something intended for a trio, so you should place a slur over the eighths regardless of whether the piano version has them.