7

I stumbled across an article by Josh Horowitz about Klezmer modes. The article gives tantalizing hints about the Klezmer modes and sub-modes but fails to fully articulate them.

  • Ahava Rabboh (Freygish)
    • in D: (B C) D Eb F# G A Bb C D
  • Mi Sheberach
  • Adonoy Moloch
  • Mogen Ovos

The modes are non-heptatonic.

What are the last three modes and are there other resources on Klezmer musical theory?

5
  • 1
    Thank you for asking this, I've been looking for resources on klezmer music for a very long time by now.
    – Pyromonk
    Jul 21, 2020 at 22:53
  • I’m voting to close this question because OP doesn't appear to have done their basic research before asking -- although it's certainly an interesting topic. Jun 27 at 0:14
  • 1
    @aparente001 lack of research isn't a close reason, but it is a downvote reason. However, it's also the case that, IMO, you're "basic research" bar is too high relative to the obviously low bar the site demands.
    – Aaron
    Jun 27 at 5:02
  • @Aaron - Oh, okay. I spend a lot of time at ELU, where some research is required. Jun 29 at 2:15
  • @aparente001 Well, others may justifiably disagree with me, but the fact that OP read and cited an article is more than many other posts here, so IMO it's enough.
    – Aaron
    Jun 29 at 2:19

1 Answer 1

4

The below definitions are scale-form equivalents between Klezmer modes and Western scales. The critical distinction is that Klezmer modes, while using those pitches, also admit additional pitches and are associated with specific motifs and moods. In this way, they are similar to Indian classical raags.

The primary resource for this post is Jewish Music Analysis, which also includes details on how these modes are used in practice.

Mi Sheberach: D E F G# A B C

The Mi Sheberach mode is described on Wikipedia as part of the entry for Ukranian Dorian scale, and a variant beginning on Db (Db E F G# A B C) is also given.

Also referred to as Misheberach, Av horachamon, Mi Shebeyrekh, and Misheberak.

Adonoy Moloch: D E F# G A B C

The site Jewish Music Analysis (which corroborates the above definition of Mi Sheberach) gives the above notation for Adonoy Moloch. It is identical to the diatonic Mixolydian mode, with the exception that the seventh degree may be raised.

Mogen Ovos: D E F G A Bb C

The same site (Jewish Music Analysis) identifies Mogen Ovos as identical to the diatonic natural minor, with a variant equivalent to harmonic minor


Regarding resources: To begin with the end of my searches, it seems that the most frequently recommended book covering Klezmer theory (among other Klezmer topics) is "The Compleat Klezmer", by Henry Sapoznik.

Here is the blurb from Amazon:

(Tara Books). This book is the definitive anthology by the world's foremost authority on klezmer music. Features an in-depth musical analysis, discography, 33 annotated melodies, historical background, annotations, resources, bibliography and extensive instruction on klezmer music. A MUST for Klezmer fans.

But some interesting resources also came up along the way.

As a starting point, Wikipedia has an article on Klezmer with a section on the Melodic Modes. That section points to another Wikipedia article on Jewish Prayer Modes, which are indicated as the source of the Klezmer modes. That section, in turn, relies primarily on Baruch Joseph Cohon's "The Structure of Synagogue Prayer Chant" (Journal of the American Musicological Society 3, no. 1, 17–32, 1950).

Cohon's primary citations are A. Z. Idelson's Thesaurus of Hebrew Oriental Melodies, volumes VII and VIII. Here is the description of the Thesaurus from the Jewish Music Research Centre:

The most important anthology of Jewish music. The first five volumes contain music of Oriental Jewish communities which Idelsohn heard in Jerusalem during the years 1907-1921. The other five volumes contain music of Ashkenazi communities which Idelsohn collected from different sources. Volumes VI and VII are based on the manuscripts of the Birnbaum Collection at the Library of the Hebrew Union College Cincinnati.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.