7

I have no problem identifying instruments, the different role they play in a song, the scales and modes of a song etcetera etcetera. I even understand harmony and the logics and theories surrounding it, I can identify the key of a song with no problem, however, when listening to songs, I CANNOT hear or identify the chord progressions in that song. Maybe I’m listening for it in the wrong way, or in the wrong place but I have been struggling with this for 2-3 years to NO AVAIL! I even posted previous questions regarding this and I still was unsuccessful with even the most thorough and insightful feedback and input from the users of this site! I’ve become so frustrated with this I can CRY!!!!!!!!

Please help! This by far is the most challenging aspect of my music theory development!

  • It would be helpful if you mention some of the ways you've tried to hear progressions. @Albrecht Hügli's answer is quite good, and you may also get some more specific suggestions based on what you've tried and what you haven't. – Aaron Jul 25 at 23:32
  • 3
    Does this answer your question? Chord progressions – Owain Evans Jul 26 at 0:20
  • 1
    Can you at least find whenever the tonic is used (or changed)? – Dekkadeci Jul 26 at 12:47
  • which instrument do you play ? – BiAiB Jul 27 at 8:55
11

First of all you should learn to identify what the bass is playing. This is not the pure chord progression but you can guess what it could be. If you sing the triad built on the root and it fits to the harmony, the bass plays the root and the assumption is correct. If not, the bass plays an inversion and there are a few possibilities.

If you analyze songs and their chord patterns from sheet music you will find that there are not so many different chord progressions, and that most songs use the same progression!

If you play and know some standard models like the I IV V I and its variations, the blues schema, I vi IV V, I vi ii V and its variations, the subdominant cadence I I7 IV iv ... you will identify them in all similar songs.

Look up for a list of the most usual chord models and compose your own songs in this progression. This is the best way to learn and internalize these progressions. And if they appear in another song you will recognize and identify them.

So play songs as many as you can, google by chords or play by ear and find the harmony by trial and error. Make your own cataloguization of songs with identical patterns. It is a long way but it will lead us to success.

Don't forget to play and practice the circle of fifths, a sequence of secondary 5ths or ii-V7 (you find them also in Bach's Preludes and other Baroque music.)

| improve this answer | |
6

What sort of music are you listening to? Anything other than guitar-based popular music may not be based on a chord progression at all.

And a lot of current 'songs' are based on chords, but not 'progressions' as we've learnt them. (As witness the number of questions here asking 'how does this work?' and the convoluted attempts to find some logical reason for a random 'progression'. The truth is that any succession of chords - particularly when they're of the same harmonic density - can 'go' well together in today's musical world.)

If it IS a 'chord progression' sort of piece, listen to the bass line. The roots of the chords will very often be prominent. Then, here's a trick. Rather than trying to hear what notes ARE in a chord, list the ones that AREN'T. Get one of the programs that loop a section, maybe slow it down, isolate a chord and find the notes that definitely DON'T fit when you play them against the recording. It can narrow the field of possible chords a lot! And maybe don't worry too much about naming chords. Just write the notes down. Parsing them as 'chord symbol' names can wait.

| improve this answer | |
  • Hey @Laurence thanks for your response! So IT IS possible for songs to NOT have a chord progression at all? I’m asking this because maybe the music and songs that I’ve been listening to don’t have chord progressions at all which is why I’m probably unable to identify it. Please get back to me regarding this comment. Thanks again! – BLG Jul 26 at 11:45
  • If you've been listening to 'songs' (like not 'classical' music) it's a fair bet that they were conceived as chords. Though there's some weird 'soundscape' stuff out there as well :-) Let's not try to make a Theory Of Everything though. I've expanded my answer a bit. Perhaps you could expand your question with examples of the sort of song you're having trouble with. – Laurence Payne Jul 26 at 15:12
4

A big majority of pop-type songs use diatonic chords mainly. Those are chords made up from the notes in their scale. Knowing the 'chord families' will be of great help.

There are 3 major and 3 minor chords in each family. I, IV and V being major, and ii, iii and vi being minor. So, in, say, key C, the majors are C, F and G, the minors Dm, Em and Am. Were it a minor key - use vii as the tonic - the other 5 will remain the same as quoted. Each key will have its own set of 6, and without knowledge of those, you could be searching randomly amongst any of the 24 majors and minors. There is viio, but that occurs so infrequently, I'm omitting it for these purposes.

You say you can fing a key. That's a good start - it gives you the other 5 chord choices quickly. Most pop-type songs will start on the tonic, so if you can tell if that's major or minor it's a great help.

As Albrecht says, the bass note is very helpful. Bass players often play one on one. That's the root note on the first beat of a bar. A really good guide as to what the chord can be called, letter wise. Don't worry about inversions - they won't change what the chord is - Am is still Am in root, 1st ot 2nd inversion.

A good move is to write out the bars on paper, 4 er line, and while listening, put in the tonics as you go. Keep that 'feel' in you, and each time you hear a tonic bar, write it in. Listen to any bar after a tonic bar, and decide (if tonic's major) whether the next bar is major or minor. If it's major, then there's a 50:50 as to IV or V. Not bad odds! Even if it's minor, there's a 33% chance of guessing correctly.

| improve this answer | |
3

The suggestions to first transcribe the bass line and the melody are spot on. This will often give you the framework of the chord progression, which, along with your knowledge of music theory, will help you work out what chords you're hearing.

However, alongside this, you should also learn to hear individual chords in each of their inversions. Here is one systematic way to approach this:

  1. Learn to reliably identify each of the four basic triads in root position: major, minor, diminished, augmented.
  2. For each of the basic triads, learn to identify each of its inversions. I recommend not mixing chord-types at this stage, just identifying for each type which inversion is being played.
  3. Finally, be able to identify all four triads in their inversions when selected at random.
  4. A similar procedure will work for seventh chords.

My experience is that hearing chord extensions and alterations (9ths, #11s, etc.) comes from having a good enough sense of the basic chords and then working with the bass/melody transcription method. Extensions will come up enough that one learns their characteristic feel as they are encountered over time.


EDIT: A quick search for "chord ear training" gave as the first result a site that appears exactly designed for the process described above.

https://tonedear.com/ear-training/chord-identification

| improve this answer | |
  • For most pop type songs, diminished and augmented chords will not feature, so being able to identify the sound of those is less important. The sevenths (yes, not triads!) are more relevant - and more common. – Tim Jul 26 at 5:33
1

In my experience, the ability to identify chords goes hand-in-hand with the ability to produce chords by ear. Through playing-by-ear exercises, the question "which chord am I hearing" is transformed into "what would I have to do to reproduce this chord". This cannot be achieved in one step, you learn to identify each chord role and type separately. First you learn to play two-chord tonic/dominant songs by ear, then three-chord songs tonic/subdominant/dominant, etc.

In your question you don't say what sort of songs and progressions you have trouble with. Maybe they're complicated and advanced songs which you cannot produce and identify by ear, before you've first learned to produce and identify simpler and more elementary songs.

Surely there must be something that you can hear and distinguish? The difference between tonic and dominant chords? A song or progression that only has C major and G major chords, can you reproduce that by ear? If yes, then how about songs that have C, F and G? If yes, then can you do C, Am, F, G? If yes, then how about C, Am, F, Dm, G? Etc. etc. There's a difficulty hierarchy you have to follow step by step. You cannot get all the way from zero to virtuosity in one step.

| improve this answer | |
0

Read about music theory,chord progressions, and finally ear training.Play as many songs as you can.

| improve this answer | |
  • 1
    Hi, Samar, and welcome to the site. You'll see, after reading a few answers, that we try to be as specific as possible with answers. Yours is rather brief, and lacking in detail which could be helpful to not only the OP, but any who read later. – Tim Jul 26 at 9:56

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.