2

I'm struggling with Gdim. The way I play it is:

  x
| | | | | |
| | | | 2 |
3 | | | | 4

I use my third finger to mute the second string but I'm not sure of the open D string. I think the chord sounds OK, but am I really playing a Gdim?

I googled Gdim and my version does not show up among the suggestions. (Tried posting to r/guitar but my post was instakilled by a modbot, yay reddit)

5

The note D is not part of a Gdim chord. You should play the notes G-Bb-Db. One way to do this would be this slightly modified version of your suggestion (from low E to high e): 3-X-X-3-2-3

Depending on the type of guitar you have, you could fret the low G (third fret low E string) either with your thumb or with your second finger. Since Gdim is a triad, you could as well just play the top three strings if you don't need the root in the bass.

| improve this answer | |
4

That's not a Gdim, because it's missing a Bb and there's no D in Gdim. I wouldn't call that a simplistic Gdim or any kind of Gdim at all. A diminished G chord has a minor third (Bb note) and a diminished fifth (Db). Yours doesn't have a third at all, and it has a perfect fifth as well as a diminished fifth or sharp 11th, so it doesn't do the job of a dim chord, the thing people mean when they write a Gdim or G° chord symbol. If you want a name for your chord, you could call it "G omit3 #11".

| improve this answer | |
  • 2
    I think the name is rather G5#11. Cool sounding chord! But indeed this is not Gdim. – user1079505 Jul 28 at 17:08
  • @user1079505 Yeah, omit3 is called "5" too nowadays, but I don't recall seeing that written with any extra tensions. "G5" means a G power chord. How would you say "G omit3 #5" with that "5" nomenclature? ;) How about G7omit3? Would that be G5 7 or what. The whole "5" business is a half-working kludge over the existing kludge of a naming system. – piiperi Reinstate Monica Jul 28 at 17:11
  • G omit3 #5 would be just two notes, giving many possible interpretation possibilities. Eb? Cm?... – user1079505 Jul 28 at 17:13
  • 1
    Also, the fact the third is missing doesn't rule it out completely as a Gdim substitute. Incomplete chord voicings are often used on guitar and other instruments. Primarily it's the presence of perfect fifth in a diminished chord which makes it not so diminished. – user1079505 Jul 28 at 17:15
  • I like the name G5#11, and I agree it's a cool sounding chord. Not a substituted for the diminished fifth, I see that now. – Emanuel Landeholm Jul 28 at 18:04

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.