8

enter image description here

enter image description here

This is from the book "tonal harmony",

the 14th chord is vii half diminished 7; consisting of the notes D# F# A C#, with A in the bass, therefore it is vii half diminished 4 3, second inversion, which makes sense to me

but the 16th chord is what's confusing me, it has notes F# A D#, without a C#, the textbook answer says it's vii half diminished 6, first inversion, but can a triad be half diminished? I thought only seventh chords could be HALF diminished, the 6 clearly states that it's a TRIAD in first inversion, and the slashed circle states that it is half diminished,

so can a TRIAD be half diminished?

(UPDATE) It seems there are multiple errors/typos in this book, I have spotted even more typos after further reading

2
  • It might be a reminder that a four-note chord built on the 7th step of a major scale is half diminished. But a triad indeed can't be half diminished. I wonder what the "vii°" in the last bar of example 3 refers to? Are they at least consistent within the book? Commented Aug 30, 2020 at 23:50
  • They are consistent for the most part
    – user64861
    Commented Aug 31, 2020 at 0:50

4 Answers 4

4

Your analysis is correct, and this seems to be an error in the book, in which chord 16 in the answer key should include an open circle rather than the slashed circle.

A half-diminished chord is, by definition, a seventh chord -- thus requiring a (minor) seventh, which chord 16 lacks.

Note that the excerpt itself is a correct reduction of the original. Here is the passage in question from the Bärenreiter Urtext.

enter image description here

3

A triad can be diminished - with a m3 and a d5. A fully diminished chord will be that triad plus a dim 7,the same sounding note as M6. In key C - C, E♭, G♭ B♭♭.The last sounding like A.

The 'half-diminished' part of a chord comes when a m7 is added, instead of that d7. That's why it's only 'half-diminished' as opposed to 'diminished', or 'fully-diminished'.

So it would appear that there's a typo - or it's just incorrect.

Sometimes, it's easier to understand when it's called m7♭5, as that portrays all the relevant details.

4
  • In precise terminology it's a fully diminished seventh chord, so called because both the seventh and fifth are diminished. In other words, the distinction between B-D-F and B-D-F-A♭ is the word "seventh," not the presence or absence of any modifiers on the word "diminished." This is of course complicated by the fact that in imprecise terminology people often use "diminished" as shorthand for "diminished seventh."
    – phoog
    Commented Aug 30, 2020 at 17:22
  • But half diminished chord is not a variant of minor seventh, which the notation m7b5 erroneously suggests.
    – Divide1918
    Commented Jul 1, 2021 at 13:13
  • @Divide1918 - it's a variant. A dim is A C Eb Gb. A half dim is A C Eb G. Am7 is A C E G. All varying by one note moved a semitone. Unless you use 'variant' as a sustitute for 'inversion'. But - to whom was the comment directed?
    – Tim
    Commented Jul 1, 2021 at 13:19
  • @Tim But they're all different types of chords. It's like saying Cmaj11(#11) and C9(#11) are variants of each other. How could a major chord be a variant of a dominant 11th? Also by your logic, almost all chords of high enough extension (like 11, 13) are more or less variants of each other.
    – Divide1918
    Commented Jul 1, 2021 at 13:25
1

The triads (there are only triads of 3 tones) are built by 2 minor thirds in root position. (m3dim5)

You are right, a triad ti-re-fa (here D#-F#-A) is diminished, in respect to the diminished 5th.

Half diminished is the VII7-5 tetrad: ti-re-fa-la (or iim7b5 in minor - like Tim says)

A diminished tetrad is built by 3 minor thirds e.g. ti-re-fa-lu or si-ti-re-fa: the vii dim7 chords of the major and minor keys.

0

The question is, "Can a three note triad be half diminished." Starting with a major triad, you can flat the fifth and leave the third major...C(b5), etc. But it's not called a half diminished. It's a "major, flat 5". The term "half diminished" is reserved for seventh chords.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.