1

I am aware of this previous question Wireless Guitar Systems. However it is nearly ten years old. The technology has probably changed and the emphasis of my question is different.


Background

I am taking up guitar again after a long absence. Currently I'm playing mostly at home to get my skills back up to speed. I occasionally play at a social get-together. I would like to try wireless technology both at home and at the occasional gig away from home.

enter image description here

Problem

In reviews I see that some wireless systems can be sensitive to home broadband WiFi and produce annoying pinging noises constantly. Given that WiFi is so prevalent now (and that I also have it in my home), I wonder if Wifi interference is a regular problem these days.

Question

Does anyone here have experience in this area and, if so, is it only the cheaper systems that have the problem? Does it make sense for me to start cheap and work my way up or will interference plague me no matter how much I spend?

Note

I don't anticipate getting further than about 15 feet (4.5 m) from the receiver. At home my broadband WiFi and guitar equipment will all be in close proximity - within a radius of about 8 feet.

2
  • AFAIK there are lots of different wireless technologies and even more possible combinations, and what sort of radio jungle you're entering depends on the location, legislation and regulations etc. Imagine PAL, NTSC, 50Hz, 60Hz, 110V, 230V, driving on the right side, driving on the wrong side etc. and multiply that by a million. New products and technologies are being introduced all the time, so what's good somewhere today may be bad tomorrow. You'll have to test it properly and have a wired backup system anyway. It's not that expensive to try. Or limit the question to a specific country. – piiperi Reinstate Monica Nov 24 '20 at 11:44
  • @piiperi Reinstate Monica - Thanks, good tip. I've added the country (England, UK). – chasly - supports Monica Nov 24 '20 at 11:52
2

I have 3 generations of wireless kit for gigging, and the oldest is very much analogue, from back in the early 90's. Then I have an early 802.11b kit (on 2.4GHz), and a much more modern Line 6 Relay G55 (also on 2.4GHz) from about 7 years ago.

The earliest one suffers from interference any time anything is broadcasting on a channel close to its frequency - nothing I can do about it. It has no interference protection.

The 802.11b kit copes well even when there are multiple devices on 2.4GHz - it only ever had problems in venues where I might want to move far away from the receiver, and had columns/people in between. It didn't cope well with that, but never suffered from interference, just low signal.

And the G55 works everywhere - doesn't suffer from interference from large numbers of devices on 2.4GHz, copes with multiple routing paths in weird venues.

Your XVive is possibly not quite as robust at seeking out channels that are free of interference as the Line 6, but for your purposes it will cope perfectly well. There is actually a lot of space in the 2.4GHz band as you will have noticed if you have kids and they bring their friends round - and everybody has a phone connecting to your wifi :-)

3
  • Thanks. (I don't have an XVive, I was just using it as an illustration). The G55 looks amazing - I don't anticipate serious gigging this time around so maybe it's overkill. Looking at the XVive, I see complaints about charging amazon.co.uk/product-reviews/B01N4DSQBR/… – chasly - supports Monica Nov 24 '20 at 12:53
  • The G55 was an awesome price point when I went looking, and the rackmount receiver is awesome. The battery life is good too. Hadn't seen that about the XVive charging - there are a few competitors in that market though so you should find something. – Doktor Mayhem Nov 24 '20 at 12:55
  • 1
    I've never used rackmount - never been that serious. One factor for me is to maximise portability. Maybe I'll take a punt on the XVive - after all those were the worst reviews. I'll look at the good reviews as well. If I ever start gigging seriously again, I'll go the big guns and get a G55! – chasly - supports Monica Nov 24 '20 at 13:00

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.