10

Aren't the different parts of it having a different pitch? Can't this be used to play a melody?

2
22

A drum is usually considered a non-pitched instrument because it produces a weak fundamental frequency, produces inharmonic overtones, and the pitches it does produce are unrelated to the rest of the ensemble. Certain drums can take on more pitch-like qualities by modifying some of these parameters.

A plucked string, for example, has a very strong fundamental frequency which is perceived as the loudest, which is the note you hear when plucking the string. It also produces harmonic overtones which are integer multiples of the fundamental frequency, which are related to the pitch of the note in a very simple manner. The plucked string's fundamental frequency must also somehow match the rest of the ensemble, or it will sound out of place.

A drum, on the other hand, does not produce a very strong fundamental frequency, as it produces many different frequencies that are perceived similarly. The many frequencies it produces are inharmonic, as there's no simple integer relationship between overtones. The lack of a strong fundamental frequency also means that you don't really need to worry about how it sounds with the rest of the ensemble - even though you can tune a snare drum up or down, it will never sound "out of tune" with the rest of the ensemble, since there's no single, easily identifiable pitch that's produced. Drum pitches are typically described in the context of the other drums in the set, rather than their relationship to pitched instruments, and drum pitches generally do not have any harmonic relationship.

That said, unpitched drums may be considered pitched depending on how they're tuned and played. A floor tom, for example, could be played gently with soft mallets to bring out the fundamental frequency or harmonic vibrational modes better (similar to how one plays timpani), rather than simply striking it with a hard stick. There won't be a hard line between pitched and unpitched, as it'll depend on the perception of the fundamental frequency and overtones. You could imagine starting with a pure pitched tone and progressively adding inharmonic overtones - the note will seem more and more non-pitched, but it'll be a fairly continuous transition from pitched to non-pitched.

EDIT: Thanks for the many comments on fundamental frequency and harmonics. Ultimately, the non-pitched nature of a drum comes its many vibrational modes and how those modal frequencies are related. Below is a figure of the first eight vibrational modes of a circular drum. The numbers in parentheses show the number of non-moving nodes in the angular and radial coordinates, respectively, while red and green show opposite directions of motion of the drum head (from this interesting page about drum physics). The value of f denotes the modal frequency, which is the pitch of that particular vibrational pattern. When striking a drum, many more of these vibrational patterns occur at the same time, each contributing to the overall sound of the drum.

enter image description here

Every mode is characterized by a modal frequency, which can be expressed as a multiple of the fundamental frequency (the entire drum head oscillating up and down). Most modal frequencies of the drum aren't related in a manner pleasing to the ear, so there is no discernible pitch for most drums. Drums with pitch qualities, like timpani or pitched toms, excite particular modes that are related in a more "musical" way, so they are perceived as having pitch.

A string's vibration has only one dimension instead of two, and its vibrational modes have modal frequencies related in a much simpler manner than a two-dimensional drum head. That's why there's no such thing as a non-pitched violin.

11
  • 3
    I'm now waiting for this comment thread to fill with drummer jokes. "I hit it, it go boom" "Give me an A."…"Eh?" etc etc etc
    – Tetsujin
    Feb 26 at 17:30
  • 5
    Drums can produce a strong fundamental frequency if they're tuned for it. The drums in modern rock and metal recordings tend to have very strong fundamentals and yet still are unpitched for practical purposes. And timpani, which are considered pitched, effectively have no fundamental at all! The reasoning that strong fundamental <=> pitched instrument doesn't hold up. Also, some pitched string instruments have harmonics that are stronger than the fundamental.
    – Edward
    Feb 26 at 17:36
  • 1
    Yes, I was wonder why no one mentioned timpani or other pitched drums. Feb 26 at 17:41
  • 1
    More seriously than my last comment - talk of pitched drums always makes me think of the snare in The Commitments - Mustang Sally which I loved when I first heard it, but across the whole album it gets tiring. (Although, you have to bear in mind that we'd been through 2 decades of dead/damped then electro drums, followed by gated reverb, so this was a "new thing" at that time)
    – Tetsujin
    Feb 26 at 17:51
  • 2
    I think this a good answer overall but I agree with @Edward that it places too much emphasis on the idea of having a strong fundamental. You can have a note with absolutely no energy at all at the frequency of the fundamental, and yet the note may be perceived as having the pitch of that fundamental. Notes at the bottom end of the piano have weak fundamentals, but we wouldn't describe them as unpitched.
    – topo morto
    Feb 27 at 9:49
6

Beyond questions of harmonic strength, there are also questions of pitched stability. Some synthesized "percussion" instruments are almost pure sine waves, but come across as unpitched because their pitch is constantly changing. Even a 10ms snippet of a 1000-2000Hz tone can be perceived as pitched if its frequency is constant for the entire duration. A 100ms percussive effect whose pitch starts at 1500Hz and drops to 1000Hz (a rate of about five octaves/second) before decaying to nothing, however, will not be perceived as having a distinct pitch, even if it lingers on the final frequency for 10ms.

If one can pluck a guitar string hard enough without it breaking, the part of the attack may be over a semitone sharp, but guitars aren't plucked that hard in normal use, and even if a guitar is plucked that hard it will sustain for a long time with a relatively stable pitch. Drums, however, are often struck hard enough that their initial pitch is quite sharp, but don't have enough sustain to stabilize on a discernible pitch afterward. A drum might be heard as having a distinct pitch if it were played softly enough to avoid the sharp attack, but most drums have an ambiguous pitch during their attack, and their tail is too short to establish a pitch identity of its own.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.