9

Chiara Bertoglio, “A Perfect Chord: Trinity in Music, Music in the Trinity,” Religions 4, no. 4 (December 2013): 485–501, §6. A “Harmonious” God, p. 493, claims:

It was not before the 16th century, however, that the concept of “triad chord” was established9.


9. Up until then, actually, the three notes forming the triad were not conceived as a self-standing “harmonic” entity proper, but rather as the juxtaposition of two consonant harmonic intervals (cf. [54], p. 188).

Did the triad chord "as a self-standing 'harmonic' entity", not a "juxtaposition of two consonant harmonic intervals", exist in music theory before the 16th century?

5

Triads (i.e., three notes comprising "modern-day triads") existed before the 16th century, but they were not understood as "triads". The use of triads becomes more prominent around that time, however, and the theory of triads is believed to have arisen about a century later.


Three notes sounding harmoniously together goes back well before the 16th century. The composer(s) who first put three notes together is unknowable.

But as an example of "triads" occurring in music before the 16th century, here is an excerpt from Guillaume de Machaut's Messe de Nostre Dame, "Kyrie", written sometime before 1365.

Machaut, Messe de Nostre Dame, "Kyrie" first 6 beats
SOURCE IMSLP, edited by Thomas Milligan

On beat 5, we can find a E minor triad, moving to a C major triad on beat 6. However, these would not have been understood as "triads" in the sense that we use the term.

By the 16th century, the use of triads becomes more prominent, and more clearly headed in the direction of how we think of them now.

Josquin Desprez's "El Grillo" (1505):

Josquin "El Grillo" mm. 1-5
SOURCE: IMSLP, edited by Pierre Gouin

Analytically, we have several major and one minor triad, but they still would not have been thought of that way at the time.

F  |  G  Dm  |  C  (open 5th)  |  (open 5th)  D  |  (open 5th)  |  C  |

From the (Western) music theory perspective, the idea of a "triad" — that three notes form a specific harmonic unit — is generally attributed to Johannes Lippius, in the 17th century. For example:

The reception of Johannes Lippius’s path-breaking conception of the triad chiefly relies upon his [1612] treatise Synopsis musicae novae. (SOURCE)

Also

The term "harmonic triad" was coined by Johannes Lippius in his Synopsis musicae novae (1612). [SOURCE: Wikipedia: Triad (music)]

Jean-Phillippe Rameau is generally credited with first articulating the modern conception of a triad and its musical function in his 1722 Traité de l'harmonie réduite à ses principes naturels (Treatise on Harmony).

8
  • @GratefulDisciple The idea of chords and the movement between them arose out of counterpoint, which was the predominant form until the 1800s. You might find this Q&A interesting: Did continuo players consider figured bass as “interval symbols” or “chord symbols”?
    – Aaron
    Apr 16 at 4:13
  • @GratefulDisciple Put another way, composers recognized that three-voice polyphonic textures could be harmonious vertically (that was the whole point of Western polyphony — separate voices creating harmonious simultaneities), but they didn't understand it as a "triad" — that label is believed to have first arisen with Lippius in 1612.
    – Aaron
    Apr 16 at 4:17
  • @GratefulDisciple FYI: I've added a musical example that I think answers your question.
    – Aaron
    Apr 16 at 4:30
  • I understand that a continuo player would have thought of the figured bass realization as a triadic entity. But the OP asks for earlier than 1500 where the Organum tradition predominated. Do we have figured bass scores prior to 1500? Apr 16 at 4:30
  • 1
    a few other early 1400s examples, with modern staff: imslp.org/wiki/Dufay_and_his_Contemporaries_(Various) and imslp.org/wiki/Buxheimer_Orgelbuch_(Various) plenty of triads in root position and first inversion. Apr 16 at 18:39
3

Who first introduced the triad into music?

It is not possible to pinpoint a moment when the triad was introduced, much less an individual responsible for it.

But Bertoglio isn't talking about the introduction of the triad into music. She's talking about its introduction into music theory. That's why she used the phrase "concept of 'triad chord.'" Most music theory is descriptive, not prescriptive. The theory arises to describe how people make music, not to provide a recipe for a new way of composing music.

Even considering theory, we can't say when people started thinking of triads as triads; we can only say when they started writing about them, and even then there is the possibility that the first written records of the concept have been lost. Bertoglio says this happened in the 16th century. I don't know what treatise she might have in mind.

As Bertoglio notes, before the 16th century, "the three notes forming the triad were not conceived as a self-standing “harmonic” entity proper, but rather as the juxtaposition of two consonant harmonic intervals." That implies that "the three notes forming the triad" were to be found in earlier music.

Even sumer is icumin in, among the earliest examples of polyphony, attested from the first half of the 1260s, is basically an F major chord alternating with a G minor chord. But such an analysis is completely anachronistic, as nobody would have thought of it like that for the next few centuries.

Aaron mentions organum, which is documented from roughly 400 years earlier and may be (again, anachronistically) analyzed in terms of parallel inverted triads.

3
  • "'the three notes forming the triad' were to be found in earlier music." Yes, of course; I'm not doubting that. I want to know who first conceived the triad "as a self-standing 'harmonic' entity proper", not a "juxtaposition of two consonant harmonic intervals".
    – Geremia
    Apr 16 at 15:49
  • 2
    @Geremia perhaps then "when was the triad introduced into music theory" would be a more precise way of phrasing the question.
    – phoog
    Apr 16 at 16:19
  • That's probably a better way of putting it. I've changed the title of my question.
    – Geremia
    Apr 16 at 17:08

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.