5

Here is the typical note design on 10 holes major diatonic harmonica in C major: enter image description here

I have a few questions:

  1. Why there is a G key in the 2nd draw and the 3rd blow? But it omits the F key? also omits the A key?

Is that because we need more the double-note chord GB (in the 2nd and 3rd draws) or because we need more the triple-note chord DGB (in the 1st, 2nd, and 3rd draws)? More than the F key and more than the A Key?

  1. Then, why do we put A and B adjacent notes in the 6th draw and the 7th blow? Based on the above logic, we seem not to play the AB together which sounds "not a coherent chord"?

To favor the chord arguments, you can see:

  • CEG
  • DGB
  • GBD
  • BDF
  • DFA

But FAB (draw 5-7) or ABD (draw 6-8) seem to make less sense

0

1 Answer 1

8

Both of the odd aspects of the tuning you've noted are caused by the same thing: Harmonicas are originally designed to play chords! It was basically built by 19'th century Germans to play polkas.

And not necessarily just two or three notes at the time as you guessed, but possibly more! A harmonica in the key of C, as the one in your chart, was designed so that any way you could possibly blow into it produces a C major chord. When you draw, on the other hand, the entire lower half of the instrument produces a large G7 chord. This is the dominant to the C chord, and it's thus really useful when playing in the key of C. The notes DFA constitute the minor parallel of the subdominant, and you could even use the two notes FA to suggest an F major chord, the subdominant of C.

(In other terms you have the chords I, ii, (IV) and V7)

The chords are prioritised in order of importance, so that the one most important chord gets a lot of space.

The notes have been adjusted somewhat to allow for playing a melody in the upper half, but at least the bottom half is mainly intended as a chord instrument.

This doesn't mean you can't play melodies on it. In fact, people have spent over a century coming up with techniques to make the harmonica do things it wasn't intended to do. Today people are playing it fully chromatically, i.e. with all the notes you find on a piano, and some between as well! People DO play fantastic music on standard tuned harmonicas, it's just that there are quite a lot of hacks involved in their doing so.

Then, of course, no-one is forcing you to play the standard tuning if you don't like it. Though this is the most common there are many alternatives to choose from from many different brands, some tunings are even designed to play modern music ;)

1
  • many thanks! I appreciate your answer +1. I will wait for more answers/comments from others too.
    – wonderich
    Sep 9, 2021 at 20:57

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.