I have only learned a few chords in my harmony and voice leading book. I, I6, V, V6, ii, ii6, IV and the inversions of V7. I am now trying to harmonize this melody and so far the most idiomatic bassline to use for this descending line according to my book is a a pattern of 10ths between bass and soprano. So in this case it would be I6,V43,I with 5^4^3 in the soprano. However, in this case it wont work because the ^6 before the descending line is a subdominant harmony and would need to go to a dominant chord. My bassline for the ^5^4^3 doesnt really work I think. That said would my only other option be V, V7 ,I?

melody line in A major; scale degrees 5-6-5-4-3

  • 1
    Are you required to match the rhythm of the melody and harmonize every single note independently without passing tones? Also. . . what's the next note in the melody? Is it to the A? If so, I might do half-notes: A-B-D-C#. Sep 15, 2021 at 20:55
  • Correct. Every note needs to be harmonized. Next note is A
    – armani
    Sep 16, 2021 at 6:43
  • Okay in that case, I'd probably go UP to D rather than down, and then just step down the scale with the melody in 10ths, finishing up-E, down-E, up-A Sep 16, 2021 at 9:15
  • Are you not allowed to use repeated or held notes in the bass when harmonizing? I'd personally use only E for the bass under ^5 ^4 to go with V-V7.
    – Dekkadeci
    Sep 16, 2021 at 11:52

1 Answer 1



Idiomatically, the best options in this specific instance are:

  1. The given solution
  2. Parallel 10ths
  3. Voice exchange

Parallel 10ths

I mention this first only to reiterate what's already written in the OP. Parallel 3rds, 6ths, and 10ths are highly idiomatic, so that's always a good place to start when considering a harmonization. See below for why it's a very good solution in this particular case.

Contrary motion / voice exchange

Another highly idiomatic option is to counter the soprano 5-4-3 with 3-4-5. This is called "voice exchange", because the soprano and bass (in this case) swap scale degrees 3 and 5. Harmonically this would generally be I6-IV-I64 or, less commonly, I6-ii6-iii.

Voice exchange is just a special case of contrary motion. Once could just as well accompany 5-4-3 with 1-2-3, and harmonizing with I-V43-I6.

Regarding IV proceeding to V

This is not the only option for IV. IV (and, less commonly, ii) can also be used to prolong a I chord. I-IV-I is a perfectly acceptable progression.

This means that parallel tenths will work very well for the harmonization of the melody given in the OP.

  • 1
    Another option is to harmonize ^4 with ^3 in the bass, which is a bit difficult to analyze harmonically, then harmonize ^3 with ^4 in the bass, which more straightforwardly yields IV7. This is not what we tend to think of as idiomatic, and I first encountered it in the music of Aaron Copland, but the second place I encountered it was in the music of J. S. Bach. It doesn't work if you're cadencing on ^3, but that's not the case in the example given in this question.
    – phoog
    Sep 15, 2021 at 22:28
  • @phoog Big bonus points if you can find the Bach reference!
    – Aaron
    Sep 15, 2021 at 22:32
  • Aaron My textbook says thay intermediate chords move to dominant chords not to tonic chords. Later in the book (because I skip ahead from time to time) it does discuss IV going back to I but the level that I am on only allows intermediate Harmony to move to dominant Harmony. Having said that, the IV chord on beat 2 cannot move to I or I6 right? Also, your I6 ii6 iii harmony involves bass notes 3-4-3 not 3-4-5. Please let me know if this is right?
    – armani
    Sep 16, 2021 at 6:51
  • Can you please explain your proposed solution of parallel tenths using I IV I for 5-4-3?
    – armani
    Sep 16, 2021 at 7:08
  • @armani I-IV-I6-V43-I
    – Aaron
    Sep 16, 2021 at 7:49

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge that you have read and understand our privacy policy and code of conduct.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.