If these melody notes appear in a harmony exercise where you are allowed to use only V V7 and I to harmonize a melody would the logic be too harmonize all 3 with V since you are going from the leading tone down to the 5th scale degree and in the soprano the leading tone would resolve to ^1 unless the V chord was being extended. Similarly, if you see ^4 going to ^5 then would the logic be to also use V7 for both since you wouldnt have a 7th not resolving down in the soprano unless the dominant harmony is being extended?

  • 1
    Might make more sense if the example was shown - note values and places in the bar can affect what harmonies work more effectively.
    – Tim
    Oct 23, 2021 at 13:49
  • Even only using V and I there are tons of options. The 2nd scale degree can sound great as a ninth above the root of the I chord. Similarly with the 7th scale degree. And of course the fifth degree is a chord tone for both. It’s kinda like there’s no wrong answer Oct 23, 2021 at 19:24

1 Answer 1


Yes, you can harmonize 2-7-5 with only V, you could also with V7, or you could e.g. use V for the first two notes and V7 for the last one to add movement and tension.

Using V7 for 4–5 makes sense if you're limited to I and V and V7, indeed otherwise non-resolving 7th would be an issue. Maybe an alternative could be to treat 4 as a passing note, then you could harmonize both notes with I?

  • Thanks. In this case each note in the melody gets its own chord so a passing note wont work. Good idea about adding the V7 though. I will try that because right now it sounds bland using V for all 3 notes.
    – armani
    Oct 23, 2021 at 13:37

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.