9

I found this very interesting notation in Wiklund's first piano concerto, final bars of movement 1 (the transcription for two pianos):

extract from Wiklund's piano concerto

See the final left-hand bars: the low E is sustained over a clef change, then into the next bar where the two clefs are stacked atop each other, both applying to one note.

I have never seen that notation before and I doubt that many music notation programs would support it. So that sparked my curiosity; how would a modern musician notate the same passage? Is the only alternative to move the high B to the right-hand stave?

3
  • 1
    Concerning whether music notation programs could produce this output: I suspect you could induce Lilypond to produce that output if you really wanted to. But I'm not experienced enough with it to be able to produce a working example quickly. Dec 24, 2021 at 14:43
  • Any notation program could easily produce it, as long as it had non-functional symbols available of treble and bass clef. Playback would need to be cheated though. Dec 24, 2021 at 20:30
  • @LaurencePayne Definitely true, I meant that I doubt any software supports it natively.
    – KeizerHarm
    Dec 24, 2021 at 21:29

2 Answers 2

5

3 alternatives to that notation that I can notate with Musescore are these:

  • Cross-staff the lower staff's uppermost B so the slurred beam in the lower staff of the 3rd last measure connects a chord in the lower staff with a note in the upper staff
  • Use 3 staves instead of 2 (heck, this also looks appropriate for the 4th last measure)
  • Notate the lower staff's uppermost B with 4 ledger lines in the bass clef instead of using the treble clef

I don't have the greatest clue which of these is the best, but given that I had to count out the ledger lines in order to determine what the bottommost notes are (turns out they're E's), I personally would not want to read my last option.

2

Occasionally, this can be a useful and clear way to notate something which would otherwise look messy. I don't think it's a particularly 'old' way.

Any notation program that supports clef symbols as simple, non-functioning graphic objects could notate this. Playback would be another matter! (Though easily enough achieved by muting the displayed notes and adding them in an additional, hidden voice).

Here's a practical alternative. I suspect I prefer it as notation. But it's not fun getting the ties to go where you want them. in Sibelius at any rate! (You'll note that I copped out of the challenge. Give it a try in YOUR notation program.)

enter image description here

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.