Phil Kraus' Modern Mallet Method (Vol. 1, p.11) states (with illustration) that the correct placement of mallets is "left mallet above the right". However, Buyer & Gottry in The Art of Vibraphone Playing emphasize striking the bar in the same place except, "in rare cases where rapid rhythmic figures or rolls are required on the same bar, the mallets should be off-set, with one mallet just above the center of the bar." Other method books I've inspected (e.g., G. H. Green, M. Goldenberg) don't remark on this one way or the other.

I'm certainly finding left-over-right to be both easier to control (i.e., avoiding mallet collisions). Also, I'm loathe to discount Kraus' explicit direction given his historical importance as a performer and instructor. However, given my comfort level with it I'm concerned that if left-over-right is not the preferred modern approach it will become an ingrained habit rather quickly and lead to problems later on. For those that have had the benefit of personal instruction (at this time I do not) what has been the received wisdom on this issue?

  • Surely it would depend on the actual notes being played, right? And in cases where the notes are "symmetric", there's no real downside to picking the left hand to be more north, rather than the right.
    – Edward
    Jan 13 at 23:27

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.