According to this page, harp pedals are notated as
D C B E F G A.
In the score for Holst's Planets - 7. Neptune, the order
Cb D# Eb G# Ab B F#
was used. Is there a specific reason for this non-standard notation?
-
2I'm very interested to hear from someone who knows (I don't, even though my daughter is learning harp!). I wonder, in particular, whether scordatura is involved? It's striking that three pairs of enharmonic equivalents are used, D#/Eb, G#/Ab, and Cb/B (note, you might want to edit your question to show this). The opening notes show why: the harpist alternates between two chords that are enharmonically equivalent, G# B D# and Ab Cb Eb, giving the effect of a rapid tremolo on a single pitch. I wonder whether they have to deviate from the standard tuning to accomplish this? Not sure.– Andy BonnerFeb 8, 2022 at 15:30
-
Only thing I can think of is a different kind of harp might have been used. Or maybe a translation/transcription error?– Todd WilcoxFeb 8, 2022 at 15:49
-
2This may be a age related thing. Your first link refers to a recently written document but that score is about a hundred years old. Your first document also insists that the pedal markings are NEVER in the middle of the staves - but look where they are in the score.– JimMFeb 8, 2022 at 17:39
-
I think your question is clear when looking at this specific page harpnotation.com/the-harp/pedal-mechanism/pedal-diagrams– Michael CurtisFeb 8, 2022 at 19:07
-
2I think it's worth noting that the pedal order is not consistent throughout the piece.– Elements in SpaceFeb 9, 2022 at 0:59
|
Show 3 more comments
1 Answer
This is from my Walter Piston Orchestration book...
...the pedal notation can be given as scale degrees, letters grouped by the left/right pedal positions, or graphically as black marks on, above, or below a line.
Looks like Holst opted for the scale ordering.
answered Feb 8, 2022 at 19:16
-
1
-
I edited my answer to take out the "alphabetical/scale order", that was my wording, not Piston's. The F being last doesn't really matter, the pedaling is clear: set F to sharp. The letter order is odd, but you can still see the settings. Feb 8, 2022 at 20:06
-
My read of the question is that it’s asking why the pedal order is odd. This doesn’t seem to be a complete reason why, because it doesn’t offer an explanation for why the F is listed last. Feb 8, 2022 at 21:01
-
Yeah, I get that. But maybe there isn't a reason. If there isn't a requirement to indicate pedals in the first place, if given, why assume they must be in a particular order? Feb 8, 2022 at 21:27
-
Holst found he'd missed the F setting and so put it at the end, and his editor didn't notice?– PeterMar 14, 2022 at 16:17