4

I'm seeing two version of the Bach Sinfonia 9, measure 13, should it be a G flat or G natural on the top voice? G flat makes the most sense, since it keeps with the motif. But why most recordings have the G natural which sounds super odd? Even the Henle urtext version has the G flat, no accidental. It makes no sense to me. Thank you!

2
  • The major third sounds a bit jarring if you're expecting a minor third and some editions change the note to G-flat. If you prefer the G-flat, there's nothing stopping you from playing it that way.
    – PiedPiper
    Apr 5 at 9:37
  • Neither Bach nor Sinfonia are near to unique. Can you confirm, that Johann Sebastian and BWV 795 from two- and three part inventions is the topic of your question?
    – guidot
    Apr 6 at 15:12

1 Answer 1

1

I disagree that G flat sounds better. This section brings the theme in e flat major, and both soprano and bass consistently use g and not g flat throughout. The counterpoint still uses the chromatic passages which characterize the whole Sinfonia, but nevertheless this passage is definitely in e flat major.

3
  • Are you saying that Gb is incorrectly given in the urtext?
    – Aaron
    Apr 5 at 9:53
  • 1
    @Aaron it's clearly not a G flat in either of the manuscripts available on IMSLP. Presumably the editor of the Henle edition had a reason for deciding that it should be a G flat, and I suppose that the critical notes explain, but I don't have the edition handy to check.
    – phoog
    Apr 5 at 10:28
  • @phoog The critical notes say nothing about that note. It's given as Gb without commentary.
    – Aaron
    Apr 5 at 12:25

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.