Do singers use functional (scale degree) ear training method or interval ear training method to find a reference pitch from the accompaniments to start singing in key?

for example, the accompaniment is a piano and a C major chord played but the first note I have to sing is D, do I Imagine major second relative to C in the C major chord or Is it possible to use the functional ear training method to imagine the sound of the supertonic relative to the overall key?

  • 1
    Don't over-think this. The tonic chord establishes... well the tonic. It gives you your bearings. So the melody starts on a non-tonic note. Are you actually finding this a practical problem?
    – Laurence
    Nov 15, 2022 at 11:09
  • I'm not sure what "functional ear training" means in this context. Any good ear training program teaches interval recognition as well as a sense of scale degree, whether it's fixed or moveable do. And ultimately, interval recognition and tonicicity work hand-in-hand. Sing a C followed by an F#? Yes, it's a tritone and a leading tone to the dominant, and you're aware of both at once. Nov 15, 2022 at 14:37

2 Answers 2


Singers use both methods.

In the situation described, for example, I would do one of three things:

  1. If the accompaniment contains a D at some point before I enter, I would listen for it, and then hold onto that pitch until I enter.
  2. I would listen for the C or the E in the C major chord (whichever is easier to pick out) and sing a second above or below, respectively.
  3. Once I know what key the piece is in — for example, the C major chord might actually be the IV chord of G major or the III chord of A minor — I might use my functional harmonic training to find D according to its position within the primary key rather than a particular chord.

Either and both. Using the interval method would give, in your example, hearing the root, knowing D is a major second above, and pitching that.

Scale-wise, D is the 2nd note (^2), so again, hearing and recognising C, I'd sing the very next scale note up - D.

Or, Use a chordal method, where I know that D on a C chord makes Csus2 (properly Cret2), I'd 'hear' the D from that chord to pitch it correctly.

Other singers may not even think about what they do - they'll hear the C chord, and automatically pitch a D note. However, D against a C chord generally leads to a chordal note (C, E or G) so another option, knowing the melody, is to tag a D note onto the front of the almost inevitable E (sometimes C) that will follow. 'Yesterday' is a fine example of that.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge that you have read and understand our privacy policy and code of conduct.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.