Simple straightforward question: What is the minimum pedal keyboard range needed to play ALL of J.S. Bach's pipe organ music?
Optional ways to embellish the answer:
Did Bach ever write a piece for which the organs he had at his disposal at the time (let's say during his time at Weimar, 1708-1717) did NOT have sufficient range? One example:
- (Thanks to @KilianFoth for the finding) Fantasia in G major, BWV 572 (score here) has a B that is a semitone lower than the lowest C (measure 94). How would an organist play that note since most organ pedal keyboards, even today, start with C? An ingenious solution is for an assistant (who already helps with page turning, etc.) to pull a 32' stop just for that note, as clearly seen in this performance (minute 3:50). The stop used in the organ at St. Catherine's, Hamburg is the Groß-Posaune 32'. In this audio-only performance (minute 3:41) on the Trost organ, Waltershausen, the organist probably used the same trick since he listed the pedal registration he used without the 32' stop but the organ does have a Posaunen-Bass 32'. But if the organ doesn't have a 32' stop (such as the Vater-Müller organ, Oude Kerk, Amsterdam), then the organist would need to play that B an octave higher (minute 3:50).
- This article (thanks to @phoog) has more discussion about that "impossible B" along with other "impossible" notes Bach wrote.
Which organ pieces require a pedal keyboard beyond 2 octaves, assuming the lowest note is C? An interesting etude for pedal by Bach is Pedal Exercitium (BWV 598, in G minor, critical edition score here) which calls for exactly 2 octaves (C-c1) but purposefully left unfinished in the dominant. So organists provide their own extension to make the piece ends satisfactorily in G minor, who usually add more notes beyond the highest c1:
- Käthe Wright Kaufman's extension takes it to d1. See her performance in this video (minute 3:45-5:42, after introducing pianists to organ pedal technique, organ shoes, and how this piece was possibly inspired by Bach's own Cello Suite No. 1 Prelude).
- Matthias Havinga's extension takes it to f1. See the discussion of his extension (score of his extension at 0:55, and how he composed it so it naturally leads as a prelude to Bach's Fantasia and Fugue in G Minor, BWV 542) and his performance for the Netherlands Bach Society "All of Bach" project.