enter image description here

Actually this is one of exercises in the book that I am reading, and I have encountered this piece.

The chord symbol given is D7. The chord written is B/D.

How could (D F# B D#) be considered same as (D F# A C)?

I wonder such roughly putting notes together is commonplace in music?

  • What is the book and who is the author? The written voicings are often incomplete and the chord symbols often don’t match the written voicings. Commented May 14 at 7:03
  • the book is Berklee of Jazz Harmony by Mulholland and Hojnacki.
    – Sean
    Commented May 14 at 8:06
  • This offers some insight. It would also help if you gave the subject matter of the chapters your music examples contain in order to be able to answer more accurately. Commented May 14 at 8:56
  • I'd have expected it in a Mark Levine book, but not Berklee! Often there are 'approximations' - which are totally unnecessary, but those notes don't constitute D7.
    – Tim
    Commented May 14 at 9:04
  • 2
    The fundamental reason it's confusing is that the printed chord symbols are not an analysis of what lies beneath. I'm guessing the idea is that the double staff is showing what an actual pianist might choose to do here (or did, if it's a transcription?), and they've taken that basic D7 and elaborated it. But its function is still as a D chord (mostly because of the big ol' bass note). Commented May 14 at 14:33

2 Answers 2


It could be written B/D. It could even be written B7/D. Either of those would accurately describe the pitch content.

However, presuming this is an interpretation from a lead sheet, D7 clearly indicates that the chord is part of a ii-V progression (in G major, the apparent key of this [part of the] piece).

The D7 can be "heard" since the chord contains D-F#-A, and the C was just heard in the previous chord, setting the overall tonality. The B then is the 6 or 13 — a chord extension — which also describes the D# (i.e., Eb = b9).

So the symbol to describe the complete voicing would be D7b9(add13) or, since the C isn't literally part of the chord, D6b9.


Based on the fact that this is from a jazz harmony book from Berklee it seems likely this entire example revolves around using triads and 7th chords to form upper structures of basic chords. Triads used in this way are referred to as upper structure triads. These types of chords are called poly chords. They are usually written like a vertical fraction instead of a slash chord. Your example is based on a B triad over a D7 chord, written like this:

enter image description here

This ends up being a D13b9 chord. The B is the 13, the D#(Eb) is b9 and the F# is the 3. In this case the chord symbol indicates that the D7 chord is played under the triad. In this case you can spell the chord from the root but sometimes poly chords don’t have a clear single chord symbol to define them.

There are a few others here, the 1st inversion Ab triad over D7alt gives you 7,b9,#11(b5), C,Eb,Ab. The 2nd inversion F triad over Bbmaj7 gives you the 9,5,7, C,F,A.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.