13

Assume that the whole note time equals 8. Then a note which time equals 3 will be written as 1/4 note and dot. How you write down a note that time is equal 5/8 of a whole note?

  • 1
    Hi Édouard. Thanks for correcting this. as I'm completely beginner I still struggle even with basic terminology etc – szydan Feb 20 '14 at 10:03
9

As you have said, you have to use a tie for this. You can tie any combination of notes that make up 5/8ths.

However, it's also true that you can (and should) give a visual indicator of how you want the notes grouped metrically by which ties you use for the longer values. For example, if you accent the first and third 8th notes (very common in 5/8 time), use a quarter tied to a dotted quarter. If you accent the first and fourth 8th notes, use a dotted quarter tied to a quarter. And so on.

|improve this answer|||||
6

I think I've figured this out So to write such a note one would have to use a tie
Write a 1/2 note and 1/8 note and tie them together

enter image description here

|improve this answer|||||
  • 8
    This is correct, but understand that this would only be true for a duration starting at the beginning of a measure of 4/4 time. In other time signatures or positions in the measure, the same duration of 5 eighth notes may be notated differently. – NReilingh Feb 20 '14 at 1:18
  • Thanks Yes I think I'm starting to understand this better now. Reading more about ties and what to do if a note last longer then a measure. Also looking at Michael Scott Cuthbert suggestion about tuplets – szydan Feb 20 '14 at 10:48
2

There's no standard way to notate this duration without ties (as OP suggests). George Crumb uses the notation of a half note with a dot on both sides of the note for the duration (see: crumb dotes ).

You could also of course write a whole note with the tuplet [8:5] above it (any rational number duration can be written as a single note with the appropriate tuplet).

It is possible to write with standard notation a rest worth 5/8ths of a whole note: just write a whole rest in a measure of 5/8. :-)

|improve this answer|||||
  • I can't imagine why GC would choose to write a mystifying and nonstandard notatation when tied half+eighth is immediately obvious to all genres of music. – Carl Witthoft Feb 20 '14 at 12:40
  • 5
    Crumb wanted to innovate on notation and believed (so I gather) that by making a new note value that he hoped would become standard, more people would begin to use quintuple meter and consider it as fundamental to music as duple and triple meter. His notation wasn't a success, but music history is filled with similar examples, some of which worked and we now consider obvious (stem direction according to height), some were standard but disappeared later (custodes telling you the first note of the next line) and many failed. – Michael Scott Cuthbert Feb 20 '14 at 17:19
  • There is also a notation by Ian Ring (if I recall correctly) that uses a five pointed star where the dot to notate the duration of 5 eighth notes. – awe lotta Dec 8 '19 at 0:37
  • 1
    Also, it's not terribly confusing, in my opinion. If the rhythm is very prominent, and it only takes the "invention" of one symbol, then the composer could just define it in the performance notes / directions, or at the top of the score. – awe lotta Dec 8 '19 at 16:02
1

You were on the right track, but because 5/8 is an asymmetrical meter, you have to group the tie by smaller groups of the meter. In an asymmetrical meter the notes in a measure are grouped in smaller groups of two or three. The possible grouping for 5/8 are 2 eighth notes + 3 eighth notes and 3 eighth notes + 2 eighth notes. When you tie notes together, you have to abide by the groupings so the tie would be expressed as a quarter note tied to a dotted quarter note or a dotted quarter note tied to a quarter note depending on how the song groups the eighth notes.

enter image description here

|improve this answer|||||
  • The author isn't talking about 5/8 meter, he is just talking about 5 eigth notes, i.e. "5/8ths of a whole note." Though I totally agree that the rhythm should fit the metrical beats. – awe lotta Dec 8 '19 at 0:36
-2

Without ties a 5/8 note or rest is a double dotted triplet half note.

|improve this answer|||||
  • 2
    A triplet half note is 4/12 of a whole note. Double-dotting it gives you 7/12 of a whole note, which is not the same as 5/8. – PiedPiper Dec 7 '19 at 17:09
  • Moreover, a "triplet note" works only if there is a whole tripleted group. Which might not be true in the situation the OP was thinking of. – Rosie F Dec 15 '19 at 8:05

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.