5

I'm doing a research on recorder, and I got a little stuck on the part of ranges. Some says the soprano recorder's highest note goes to the 2nd octave only, but some people say that by adding a recorder bell the pitch can be higher. What exactly is a recorder bell and how do you add one to the recorder, thanks!

7

It's not a bell, it's a bell key. The bell is just another word for the end of the recorder (where most of the air comes out), and a bell key is a small construction that can partly cover the bell up.

enter image description here

The recorder can be made to play higher by carefully covering the bell -- sometimes people do this with their upper leg, but from my own experience I can tell you that it's quite difficult to pitch correctly this way. A bell key is easier to use (or so I hear -- I have never tried it myself).

2

The bell key described by Lee White was invented by Dr. Carl Dolmetsch (special keys )to help the fingering for the very difficult high C#/F# (soprano/alto) note, one half-step below the the high D/G (2 octaves+1 whole step) that all baroque or modern-design recorders should be able to play easily. Without the key one must indeed stop the bell (close the bottom of the recorder) with your knee or a pillow or something similar. Some professionals can do this with ease, even playing fast notes. It's quite showy when done well.

Composers like Telemann, Handel, etc., knew this very well and very rarely called for that note.

There are fingerings for notes above that top D/G but each recorder is different and so they won't all work and most are usually very difficult to use in practice. Telemann's highest note for alto recorders is C7, which can be played cleanly but not quietly on quality instruments.

What's happening now is that modern recorders are being made longer and have an extra key or two to provide better hole spacing for the lowest holes and even extend the range down a half-step or more. This results in better, simple fingerings for the ultra-high range, so a bell key isn't needed for those instruments. See the Mollenhauer website for an example: Soprano with B Foot

0

You can actually go further down as well by covering up the end key. On my recorders I can play a note a whole 5th lower than the lowest note if I block off the bottom of the instrument with my leg. It's really strange!

  • Really? How? I know the high bell notes, didn't realise there were low ones too. – Bob Apr 2 '17 at 21:56
  • In theory, if you completely blocked the bell, the lowest note would drop by about an octave, just like a stopped organ pipe. In practice, the shape of the recorder windway and your imperfect breath control mean you can't reach that extreme and still play a note at all. – user19146 Aug 1 '17 at 5:31
-1

The highest note on a recorder depends on the type of recorder.

The highest regular note on a baroque (default) instrument is the whole tone above the second octave, e.g. the third D on a soprano in C (which I have in fact played in concert).

The highest regular note on a Ganassi-fingered (i.e. renaissance reproduction, conical-bore) instrument is the fourth above the second octave, e.g. the third F on a soprano in C. (Fingering chart here.) It does not require bell covering. (I ♥ my Ganassi.)

  • 1
    A soprano can play higher than the D. A higher pitch can be obtained using other fingerings and covering the bell. – American Luke May 15 '14 at 21:09
  • Yes, some recorders can and some cannot. Whether or not they should is perhaps worth pondering. Even modern composers shy away from calling for the ultra-high range for smaller recorders, instead just switching up to sopranino or garkleins instead of trying to blast out a really high F#. – ohmi May 15 '14 at 21:46

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.