9

I'm really curious about the difference between polychords and extended chords. I know a polychord is two chords played at the same time where there is a higher chord and a lower chord. The common example I see C/Dm when a polychord is demonstrated, however the way I look at is just a Dm11 chord that is voiced with a closed position Dm in the lower octave and a closed position C in the higher octave.

Is there a more distinctive difference between polychords and extended chords or are they just specially voiced extended chords?

Improve this question
  • ​​​​​​​​​​​​​​If I have a sequence of notes as a chord, say, C# E G B, I could call that chord Em6 or C#m7b5 (or even C#dim#7). For most series of notes there will be multiple ways you can notate it. It's the same thing with polychords - polychords can be notated as extended voiced chords (e.g. Db/G = G7#11b9) if you want, but sometimes the polychord notation is just easier to read at a glance. – absinthe Sep 3 '14 at 7:04
8

The polychords use a fraction for a symbol, like: enter image description here, so as to distinguish from the slash chords.

From what I have understood, the point of the polychords is to help the player read and play faster. It is easier to read Abm (fraction) G7 rather than G7b9b13. The following chord can be called both G7b9b13, and Abm (fraction) G7.

enter image description here

(I know that someone can say -- Hey, just practice and you'll be able to play it -- but, it exists)

Quoting Jazzology page 15 (Chapter 2):

In practice, jazz pianists and arrangers prefer simplifying upper-structure notation so as to make the chords easy to read and play.

According to the Wiki article on Polychords, it is also used for bitonality or polytonality.

Improve this answer
  • The chord you use as an example is not exactly Abm over G7, because B and D are omitted. A polychord suggests full voicing (no omitted notes), and that very trait could be defining for the difference between a polychord and an extended chord. – SeuMenezes Oct 23 '14 at 22:01
  • One correction: B is not omitted, as Cb is an enharmonical equivalent to B. Nonetheless, D should still be there to form a full polychord. – SeuMenezes Oct 23 '14 at 22:25
  • 1
    @SeuMenezes I would argue that D is not necessary. If we can call a chord consisting of G, B, F a G7 chord, why should we reject the legitimacy of this polychord as Abm/G7 just because its G7 part is lacking the D? (unless you don't take G-B-F as G7, which begs the question: what would that be, then?) – Divide1918 Dec 7 '20 at 14:47
5

A polychord indicates an explicit superimposition of two or more chords, with full voicing, disallowing the omission of any notes. It is usually used to simplify the notation of an otherwise awkward chord symbol [think of Ebm7 over G, which could result in a bulky GMaj7(#9#11b13)], but can also make clear that the composer was thinking specifically about chord superimpositions, instead of chord alterations.

It is worth noting that a polychord can be also used to avoid the forced attribution of any harmonic function to a chord when there is no strict tonal context (for instance, a cluster, a non-tertian chord or a passing chord).

A polychord can be voiced in any way you want (open, close, interlocked or not), depending on any specific texture you intend to create.

Finally, it is rarely necessary to try seeing chords as inversions of other chords. One should trust the composer/arranger's initiative to notate a chord in such deterministic way, as to give an exact character, to influence the voicing of the arrangement, the conduction of the bass voice, and many other traits of the work being played/analyzed.

Improve this answer
4

You are right that in principle there's no difference other than that a polychord has two complete triads, which is of course not necessary for a general extended chord. Obviously, polychords are related to upper structure triads. I would say that polychords are a special case of extended chords which contain two complete triads. The main advantage is a notational one. A polychord is a simple notation for a complex chord structure.

BTW, note that polychords do not necessarily consist of two triads in closed position as you seem to imply in your question.

Improve this answer
0

A polychord may consist of the same notes as an extended chord, but that doesn'n mean it is the same thing. The resulat may sound the same, but it comes from a different way of thinking. If you take a C11, it consists of C - E - G - Bb - D - F. All of those notes refer to the C as the root. But if you have a Bb chord over a C chord, you get C - E - G, which refer to the C as the root, plus Bb - D - F, which refer to the Bd as a root note. So you have two root notes. It's a different thing, although it does consist of the same notes.

Extended chords happen in jazz and in jazz-based pop and even in rock, polychords happen in modern classical music.

Improve this answer
  • Not sure there can be two root notes for the same chord. – Tim Dec 27 '16 at 12:05

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.