11

When randomly playing chords, my husband and I stumbled upon an interesting four-note combination of C, Eb, Gb and B natural, which sounded pretty nice to us despite the dissonance. This looks like a C minor major 7th chord with a flattened fifth (CmM7b5) but i wonder whether this syntax is correct, and/or whether such group of chords exist in practical use (not merely theoretical)?

Additionally, if these chords are used in practice, what are the proper uses of them? (eg. What kind of chord should they resolve into)?

| improve this question | |
  • 5
    Yes it exists! Note that this is, in fact, the second chord of the song "The Sound of Music"! – user19475 Mar 18 '15 at 0:08
11

I usually use this chord as an upper structure of a D13(b9) chord:

(D) C Eb F# B

Used in that way, it is an altered dominant chord.

It could also be the upper structure of an Ab7(#9) chord:

(Ab) C Eb Gb B

Of course, this is also an altered dominant chord.

But it can also function as a chord in its own right, i.e. not only as an upper structure. In that case it functions as a diminished seventh chord. All its notes are contained in the C diminished scale:

C D Eb F Gb Ab A B

and the major seventh (B) is a possible tension for a dim7 chord. So in this context your chord would be a Cdim maj7 (even though you leave out the diminished 7th Bbb/A). Try adding the diminished 7th to see if you still like the sound. In this usage, it could resolve to a Cmaj7 chord by chromatic movement of the Eb and F# to the E and G, respectively. This is often done in the first bar of the jazz-standard 'Misty' by Erroll Garner.

As a final note, also note that this chord can be written/interpreted/heard as a slash chord: B/C.

| improve this answer | |
  • I'm not sure that I would agree that those are "altered" but everything else is spot on. I have heard some disagreement about what an altered dominant is made up of but I mostly commonly hear b9/#9/#11/b13, as opposed to having a natural 5 and 13. – Basstickler Feb 16 '15 at 14:50
  • 1
    @mey - I guess I'm not 100% sure where this thought comes from but I don't think I came to it on my own. The only scales that come to mind that contain a #9 on a dominant chord are the altered scale (from melodic minor) and the half-whole diminished scale, both of which would also have a b9. It may not be entirely accurate to say that #9 implies b9 but as I just mentioned, all the chord-scales that come to mind also have that b9. I guess the blues scale could be said to have a #9 as well but I'm not sure I would see a chord written as A7#9 and decide I should play from a blues scale. – Basstickler Feb 17 '15 at 21:17
  • 1
    Your suggestion to resolve the Eb and F# to E and G made me realize that this chord, although it would be spelled differently, would work very well with a B Phrygian Dominant scale. In fact, the B/C would support the tonic function and the Cmaj7 would be the predominant. – Dan D Mar 18 '15 at 17:32
  • 1
    @DanDavis: You're right: B phrygian dominant will work too. In that context I often add the note D as a passing note to make it an 8-note scale. I like that sound. – Matt L. Mar 18 '15 at 21:12
  • 1
    @DanDavis: Yes, it's a good scale for altered dominant chords, because it has the b9, #9, and b13 (and all notes of the dominant seventh chord). – Matt L. Mar 19 '15 at 14:54
0

Yeah, I'm pretty sure that's a half-diminished chord. Root-m3-d5-M7 forms a diminished triad, and that Major seventh on top keeps the seventh chord from being completely diminished, so it's "half-diminished." In a major scale, it is the chord that leads to the tonic chord. For example, if I were to play the chord that you found - C half-dim 7 - then you could play a D major after it and it would sorta resolve that dissonance that you noted.

Edit: Oops, it's actually not a half-dim because it has a major seventh on top and not a minor seventh. That's ok, though, because the seventh chord still definitely exists, and it does go with the Dmaj. Try a B-D-F-A chord also, it might sound pretty nice.

| improve this answer | |
  • 3
    Welcome to Music.SE! Does a half diminished seventh chord have a major seventh on top, or a minor seventh? – Richard Jan 12 at 18:31
  • @Richard I actually thought about this after I posted and, whoops, the minor seventh makes it a half-diminished, so y'all actually didn't play a half-dim chord; rather, you played some kind of uncommon seventh chord. Rest assured, though, it definitely exists! Also, when I grabbed my keyboard and played the C-Eb-Gb-B chord, I found that it still resolved to a Dmaj pretty nicely. I just had to train my ears to it a bit. A true B half-dim (or B-D-F-A, in case I named it wrong again) goes well with it too. – Melliefone Jan 13 at 22:54
0

Minor flat 5? That's a diminished triad!

But in all seriousness, though I'd call it °maj7, I've seen plenty of use for that chord. Built on the 4th scale degree in major, it makes a nice minor-plagal-ish sound similar to that of ivmaj7 [that's to say, Xm(maj7)]. It can function also very similarly to a fully diminished chord: iii7 to ♭iii°maj7 to iim7 sounds nice in a functional jazz context.

Rearranging and respelling the notes, one finds a potential reason for its functional sensibilities: B(â™­9)! The chord contains a major triad, and that can give this set of notes a sense of stability that diminished seventh chords lack.

Another cool thing: This chord can go really well with the G harmonic major scale [G A B C D E♭ F♯ G], and you can make some beautiful sounds out of that.

Overall, the chord seems much more closely related to the diminished tonality than the major seventh tonality, but adds a bit of stability and brightness to an otherwise tense sound. There's no "right way" to resolve this chord, but the above are some ideas on how one might get started experimenting with it. If you like the sound, who's to say you're wrong?

| improve this answer | |

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.