I have been told that two "identical" mass-produced guitars - same series, same model - can be very different in quality.

I am about to buy a new Fender from a guy who has been trying to sell it for some time (several months). The guitar looks pretty good to me, but I am concerned with its quality, since no one bought it. He is selling it a few hundred dollars cheaper than what you would find in a store, but also a few hundred dollars more than a second-hand one.

Before I go and test the guitar in person, I have this question: What can I observe to make sure it has good quality, especially when comparing to another copy of the same model?


4 Answers 4

  1. Check the neck for bowing, twisting, and any other defect. Also check the action on the neck. Check play every fret on each string and be sure that they all ring purely and that they don't squeak out. Check if the frets are worn down, which could cause squeaking. Check the intonation (play a harmonic on the 12th fret, then play the same string with the 12th fret pushed down, and see if they match closely).

  2. Check the country of origin. American Fenders are more valuable than Mexican and Japanese models.

  3. Test it through an amp. Be sure that all the knobs function properly. Check the pickup selector. Gently shake the cable at the input to be sure that it doesn't go off/on.

  4. Does it feel good? Each guitarist needs a certain size neck to fit their hand size and style of playing.

  5. Do you like the guitar? It could be perfect, but may or may not be for you. Do you like how it looks?

Good luck!


You seem to have done a little research on what the particular model Fender Guitar in question should sell for. And from your question, it appears that you have some concerns about why this one seems to have been on the market for some time.

While the other answers offer good general advice about assessing the condition of a particular guitar, my answer will be more about your concern about the value of the guitar based on make and model - assuming that it is in good condition and passes your inspection.

Obviously if you are looking at a guitar that is "several hundred dollars" less than retail and "several hundred dollars more than used" - you must be looking at a guitar that you will spend more than several hundred dollars for - so I can certainly understand that you would not want to pay "several hundred dollars" more than you should - from a sound investment point of view.

In general where I live (in the U.S.A.), a used guitar (even a brand name like Fender or Gibson) that is not a collectible or vintage or rare guitar, would be considered a good buy - if priced at about half of what it sells for new. This assumes it was well cared for and is in good condition with no damage or flaws that the other answers have properly advised you to look for.

Music stores who buy and sell used instruments will usually price them at between 60% and 70% of original price new. I am willing to pay a little more to buy a used instrument from my local Guitar Center, because I know that I have 30 days to return it if I discover problems with it after I take it home and start playing it.

Private seller's can price their instruments anywhere between the average used and new price. That does not mean they are ever going to get what they are asking for it. It does not necessarily mean that there is anything wrong with the guitar. It is quite possible, that the person selling this particular Fender, is just holding out for a higher price than the going rate for a used guitar of that make and model.

However, there are a few things you should be wary of when buying anything used, and particularly a Fender guitar.

Be sure the instrument is not stolen. You may know the person selling this guitar so you may not have that concern. But for future visitors to this site who may have similar concerns, consider that if a crook wants to sell a stolen musical instrument, he is not going to go to a pawn shop where he/she knows the serial number will be checked against police records. The crook could easily get a pay as you go cell phone (or steal one) and run an ad and sell some stolen goods and then sell the phone and disappear.

Another thing to be very concerned with on Fender and Gibson guitars, is the possibility that it is a counterfeit. It may be possible that the seller does not even know it's a counterfeit because he/she bought it used. But there is a copious supply of counterfeit Fender and Gibson guitars circulating around the world. If you choose to buy one, you don't want to pay the price of a legitimate Fender or Gibson.

Here is a good article from the official Fender Forums about how to spot a fake or counterfeit Fender guitar How to spot a fake Fender Guitar

If you don't know the Seller, you might ask for the serial number. Just say you want to research the value and you know that the serial number will tell you the age, model and other information to help you gather more information to satisfy yourself about the value. If the Seller refuses to give you the serial number, perhaps it's because he/she knows it's either a)stolen or b)fake.

Once you are convinced that the guitar is not stolen and not a counterfeit, and you have checked the action, the hardware, the electronics, the neck, the tuners, the truss rod, as described in the other great answers here, you can further research the value by consulting the Blue Book of Guitar Values Blue Book of Guitar Values

I buy used instruments often (usually from folks I know or retailers with a return policy) and I like to know that I am paying a price that is fair. So the first thing I do is look at what other used guitars of the same make and model and year have been selling for on E-Bay, or Craig's List or search on Guitar Center's website for a used one like it. I like to know the year because manufacturers often change the specs from year to year in ways that affect the value. Sometimes an older model is worth more than the newer version of the same model - sometimes just the opposite.

If it were me personally and I was buying a guitar that I was not all that familiar with from a private seller whom I did not know - here is what I would do. After I looked at the guitar and confirmed that it appeared to be in good condition and that I liked what I saw - I would say - "You know I really like this guitar and I am interested in buying it. But I have no idea what it's worth and $1,800 is a lot of money for me. Would you mind if we take it up to (Guitar Center/Music Go Round/Any Place that buy's used guitars) just to see what they would pay for it and what they would sell it for? I am certainly willing to pay more than they will pay, but as long as your price is a little less than what they would sell it for, I will feel good about your price."

I have done that a twice - but fortunately there is both a Guitar Center and Music Go Round in my area. The folks that evaluate used instruments at places like that, know what to look for and have the guitar value guides at their disposal. So if I am spending more than $1000 on a guitar from a private Seller, I feel much better if someone in the business of buying and selling used guitar, confirms the value. Another option might be just to say you would like a professional guitar repair technician or luthier to take a look at it for you. Many folks in the guitar repair business have access to value guides as well.

With a thorough inspection, a little research and due diligence, a little haggling, and a little luck, perhaps you will acquire a new addition to your guitar collection at a price you will be happy with. Good luck.

  • +1 for "Be sure the instrument is not stolen." since that indeed lowers the price of an instrument that may technically be in perfect shape!
    – wizclown
    Dec 5, 2019 at 15:40

There are a few things you might not be able to check easily when you go to see it:

  • Whether the truss rod works.
    Even if the action and setup seem perfect, do you know that the neck's truss rod will respond properly when you change to heavier strings, or decide that you want to play with a higher or lower action?

  • Whether the guitar picks up electrical hum.
    It may not be a problem in the place you try it, but in another environment you may have problems with hums and buzzes if the instrument is not shielded correctly.

  • Whether it's genuine.
    There are many fake guitars about; some are very convincing! How do you know that yours is a real Fender?

If you have problems with any of these things, will the seller take it back? Probably not. A shop, on the other hand, would have to (if it was sold as new), and that's why second hand things are so much cheaper than new ones. If your seller is asking a lot more than a typical second hand price, be careful - it might not be worth the risk.

  • If I was selling a guitar, I wouldn't be happy for a complete stranger to get out an Allen key and start turning my truss rod. Especially is he had to undo the plate over it.
    – Tim
    Mar 19, 2020 at 7:09
  • @Tim exactly - you still have to take some things on faith some when buying s/h! Mar 21, 2020 at 6:06

I would like to this add up to Mark's and the other's answers as a comment but I dont have the rep for it :)

My addition is:

  • Check all frets for chocking, it might be due to a faulty neck or due to a bad setup. So check the neck straight down and see if it seems reasonable, eg if bended backwards it would make sense that first frets might chock but if the neck seems fine, chocking frets could be due to a twist.
  • As the others said, plug it in an amp to check the electrics, just add distortion at some point, any faults will be brought up by the distortion, something that might not have been audible with a clean sound only.
  • Check how the weight seems to you. If somebody sells a gibson LP, and everything is working fine, the sound seems ok, but it weighs like a feather, then its definitely not genuine. Fake guitars might be impossible to distinguish, but the weight of the wood always gives something away.
  • Be careful when testing an instrument, because you dont have a point of reference as the instrument is new, the amp is different, the other person's setup is different than yours. If he gives you a lousy guitar plugged into great effects and a perfect tube amp, you will be falsely amazed!

Good Luck!

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge that you have read and understand our privacy policy and code of conduct.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.