1

C major chord should be (C E G), But some play (C E G C E). How does this comply with the theoretical definition of the C major chord, which is (C E G) ? What is the concept behind playing 4,5 or 6 different notes instead of 3 exact notes for a particular chord, when playing a chord with a 6 string guitar in standard tuning.

  • Were you actually told that only C-E-G was a C Major chord, or did you assume? There is no such "theoretical definition". – Matthew Read Apr 19 '15 at 22:10
  • To somebody not well versed in theory I could see there being the 'theoretical definition' of a chord and the more colloquial use of the word. For example, a power chord isn't technically a chord but we call it one anyways. @ankara CEG are the notes of a C Major chord - CEGCE is still just made up of CEG. Once we start talking about WHERE we are putting the notes we get into the study of voicings - a very profitable line of study if the mood strikes you! – Ben Kushigian May 2 '15 at 6:10
3

The three notes C, E and G constitute a C major chord. Since a guitar has normally 6 strings, it makes sense to play, sometimes, all of the strings at the same time - strum. Each string can produce one of those notes, so a 6-string chord is made. If you play bottom st. 0, 5th 3, 4th 2, 3rd 0, 2nd 1 and top 0, you have one voicing of Cmaj. Probably the most used open version. You could instead play bottom 3, and/or top 3 to make 3 other voicings. They all have the magic formula of C,E and G, but in different amounts and octaves.

Imagine a 100 piece orchestra each instrument playing a C or an E or a G, in their own range. There could be 9 or 10 different octaves of each note, but the chord is still Cmaj.

Often on guitar playing jazz, a player will play just a C and an E. The C is needed to show the root of the chord, and the E shows it's major. The G actually isn't needed, as that note is heard amongst the harmonics of the root. So you could effectively play a Cmaj with just two strings on your guitar.

2

It is the same chord. The 3 same notes are doubled. It is just another voicing of the C major chord.

-1

When someone writes C-E-G they are referring to these notes as pitch-classes, i.e. irrespective of any particular octave position. To write "C-E-G-C-E" is superfluous because the last two notes, C and E, refer to a pitch-class space already occupied by the first two notes.

On the other hand were someone to write C4-E4-G4-C5-E5, it would be appropriate and even necessary in order to communicate which particular frequencies are to be played.

In other words: C-E-G is general, C4-E4-G4 is specific, and C-E-G-C-E is redundant.

  • 1
    Hah! You sound like a mathematician - tonal congruence classes! – Ben Kushigian May 2 '15 at 6:04

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.