I'm a euphonium player, but for jazz band at school I play trombone. Everyone in jazz band is required to play an improv piece only this is my first year doing trombone, so I'm not so certain. Should I just ask to do it on the euph or should I try it, and if so, how can I make it work?

  • I'm not sure what the question is here Commented May 9, 2015 at 5:26
  • If the reason why you play the trombone in jazz band and not the euphonium is because your directors want trombones (traditional jazz instrument) and not euphoniums in the jazz band, would they really want a euphonium solo when a trombone solo is expected? I don't know what your band program is like, but if an oboe kid playing sax in jazz band might be allowed to switch to oboe for their improv, then go ahead and ask. Otherwise, I'd just take advantage of the opportunity to improve on my jazz instrument, depending on how much time I had to prepare and how question-friendly the directors were.
    – Stan
    Commented May 9, 2015 at 21:12
  • Are you asking about how to practice to get better with improvisation on the trombone, or which instrument to play this piece on (which would be off topic)? Commented Jul 21, 2015 at 1:24

5 Answers 5


You are asking, (1) which instrument will you use, and (2) what advice can we give you for getting started with soloing, which you find rather daunting at this point.

You can buy a book and play along CD. Once you've learned a tune well, you're reading to try improvising with both instruments while listening to the play-along track. Hopefully this will make it easier for you to choose your instrument to use in this ensemble.

Download some drumlines (from marching bands), then play along, improvising. This is a gentle way to get started, since there aren't any chords to worry about playing notes from.


For your first solos I suggest you write it down, practice like hell, and play that. If you want to learn improvisation on the trombone, listen and transcribe j.j.Johnson, and Curtis fuller, you will learn all the tricks


Basically, what you're asking is how to play a solo on an instrument that you are technically not very skilled at (yet) and still make it work.

What you need to do is

  1. Play fewer notes. Longer notes and more space between them (e.g. play 3 notes in 2 bars, then rest for 1 bar, etc.)

  2. Keep it simple. Choose 1 or 2 notes on each chord which you want to hear (e.g. a nice tension).

  3. Practice playing the guide tones. Then arpeggios. In the beginning, for practice, fill the bars with them so you know how to play them. Then, pick only small parts of them and leave space in between those parts.


The answer to whether to play your solo on trombone or euphonium is one of personal choice. If you want to develop your improvisation skills, trombone might be the better choice since it is a much more common instrument in jazz. You probably won't get invited to many big bands as exclusively a euphonium player.

Regarding the question of how to improve your skills, my best piece of advice is to transcribe and learn great solos. Choose solos at your level of proficiency, so for instance, you might start with the first chorus in Miles Davis classic "Walkin". Simple F blues that requires very little technique.

I just made a video about transcribing where I use a JJ Johnson solo. That particular solo might be challenging for you, but I think you'll get some value from the video:


Good luck!


Your teachers are not trying to catch you out, they are not trying to make you fail. They're trying to help you develop as a jazz player. In the jazz band you play trombone. So play trombone. This is about musical ideas, not about technique really, isn't it?

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.