1

I was just wondering if you could get time signatures where the bottom number is 3,5,6,7,9,10,11 and so on. I did not know if you could have dotted notes as your base note

  • 1
    Yes, they exist, but note that they only make sense when also at least one other time signature (with a different denominator) appears in the same piece. A piece with only one time signature, e.g. 3/3, could better be written as 3/4. – Matt L. Jun 21 '15 at 11:32
2

Yes. This kind of time signature is called Irrational.

An irrational time signature is one where the denominator isn't a power of two (like the examples you provided).

There has been another similar question here;

Where the asker provides a link from Wikipedia that has many compositions in irrational time signatures.

  • The Wikipedia article doesn't include the word "irrational", and as far as I can see doesn't include any time signatures not having a power of 2 on the bottom. (And it's not clear why anyone would use the name "irrational" for 2/3, unless only to demonstrate that they don't understand any mathematics.) The other number you quote is some sort of joke. – Brian Chandler Jun 21 '15 at 11:46
  • 1
    @BrianChandler did you even look at the first link? – Shevliaskovic Jun 21 '15 at 11:55
0

No, basically. But of course it depends on what you mean by "could you get?"

A time signature has a bottom number (it's not a denominator, because a time signature is not a fraction) which is a power of 2, representing one of the series of binary-divided notes from semibreve ("whole note") downwards. The top number shows how many of these note-values make up a bar (measure). It would be nice if the bottom number showed how big a beat is, but this is not true: if each beat is a dotted crotchet, then the number on the bottom "ought" to be 3/8, but instead 8 is written on the bottom, and the number on the top is the number of beats multiplied by 3. Similarly, if there are 3 beats each divided into 5 quavers, the time signature is 15/8 (e.g. Scriabin op. 11-14). (And of course this is ambiguous: it could be 5 beats of dotted crotchets.)

You asked about numbers like 3, 5, 7 etc., but unfortunately it is not clear what these would mean, because they do not obviously refer to any sensible notes: if my binary arithmetic is to be trusted, 1/3 in binary is 0.010101..., so 3 on the bottom means that each beat is represented by (let's use American here!): 1/4 + 1/16 + 1/64 + ..., and unending series of notes.

Meanwhile, those regarding fame as more important than music can write anything they like, any some people may buy it.

Carl Orff in Carmina Burana (and I guess elsewhere) pioneered a much better system in which you write the note symbol for each beat (including dotted notes) on the bottom, and the number of beats on the top, but this has never really caught on.

  • 4/3 would actually be very simple. It just means you have 4 notes which are each a third of the length of a whole note. This corresponds to 1 1/3 half note triplets per bar. – Caters Feb 6 at 21:25
  • So what symbol would you write the "1/3" note with? – Brian Chandler Feb 7 at 6:21
  • I have seen incomplete triplets for irrational time signatures written and usually they are written almost like a complete triplet except there are only 1 or 2 notes and no rests. But other than that, they are written like any other triplet. – Caters Feb 7 at 6:37
  • A picture would help. But if there are 1 or 2 notes, how do they "look like a triplet"? Do they have a '3' underneath? – Brian Chandler Feb 8 at 17:34

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.