1

I'm busy with the first symphony of Peter I. Tchaikovsky. In movement 1 the time signature is 2/4. Can someone explain the choice of putting 2/4 instead of 4/4. If it goes with the feel I don't feel 2/4 more then 4/4? Or there are other parameters that made him choose 2/4.

  • 1
    Even if it's not 100% clear to all listeners, it is likely that Tchaikovsky intended musicians and conductors to have a march mentality while performing the movement. Whether the movement is so fast that it's very hard to hear the difference may not matter. One thing that helped me understand 2/4 versus 4/4 was learning how clearly 6/8 (compound 2/4) is different from 12/8 (compound 4/4). To me, the differences between the compound time signatures is a lot more audible. – Todd Wilcox Dec 29 '15 at 14:08
  • @Todd with the 6/8 I feel it alright. But I never thought of taking it to 12/8 that's a good idea. – Nachmen Dec 29 '15 at 16:06
1

In general a (classical) 4/4 signature emphasises the first and third beat, with the first beat being emphasised slightly (but noticeable) more than the third beat.

In a 2/4 signature, the first beat is emphasised in each bar to give it a march feel. Think 1 2 1 2.

If one was to rewrite a 2/4 as a 4/4 then one would lose the equal emphasis on every first beat in the bar, replacing alternate 1's with a slightly less emphasised third beat.

  • I got the gist of what you're saying. But the tempo is so fast it's q=132 I almost don't feel nothing? What I do feel is the musical sentence and that gives me the feeling of 4/4. – Nachmen Dec 28 '15 at 23:59
  • 2
    @Nachmen I've just had a quick listen to it and you're right that the march feel is subtle and really only felt when the full string complement enters after about a minute, and even then only intermittently. There is a lot of dynamics layered on top of the underlying string ground which make the march feel, at times, far from evident. The march of winter in a blizzard of sounds. – UserZero Dec 29 '15 at 0:16
  • Thank for reaffirming my doubts. It's the don't know feeling. I'm still making sense. – Nachmen Dec 29 '15 at 1:13
  • I took a metronome and sang the tune as best to my ability, you do see a difference. When the metronome is on 2/4 it fits in more naturally. – Nachmen Dec 30 '15 at 9:29

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.