1

I have a "Real Easy" ear training book and it uses solfege, but I have a real hard time with that. I use a guitar tuner app to check myself and I find I can hum much better than singing "do's",ect. Is this going to be a major hindrance to my ear training or can I replace one with the other as I make my way through the book ?

  • I've read that one should not hum for ear training, but I don't remember where or have any support for that. It does make up a part of some vocal warmups for singing. It is a very different process, mechanically, from singing, all things considered, and might not develop the same pitch sense. – Todd Wilcox Jan 5 '16 at 16:52
3

The argument I heard as a student was that movable "do" allows you to make a mental association between scale degrees and solfege syllables. After a lot of practice singing with solfege syllables, the syllables tend to start popping into your head as you hear a melody. That gives you a way to fix those pitches in your mind and remember them, so that (for example), you can then transcribe the melody or play it on your instrument.

0

You asked: "...can I replace one with the other as I make my way through the book?"

I think the answer is no. Your book is using those syllables for good reasons; like Bruce wrote, they allow you to make a mental association among notes (whether your book uses movable "do" or fixed "do"). As you progress further in your book, I imagine those syllables will become more and more critical to the training contained within it.

Singing in syllables is not an intuitive skill. It takes a great deal of practice in the beginning. Stick with it, and get good at it. There are huge benefits to being able to sing by syllables! It may seem strange at first, but it will make sense later, so drink the "coolaid," so to speak, and have faith.

  • I think what is confusing is, if I'm using an app as a note meter, and I sing do, will the meter show sol as a perfect fifth if I am doing it right ? – mike628 Jan 5 '16 at 19:08
  • You're using the tuner to help verify you're singing a perfect fifth? Well, I'd do that by playing a "D" on an instrument, singing that, then singing the perfect fifth above, and checking with the tuner that you hit "A". (Or, use some other notes, whatever's most comfortable for your voice.) Or check by just playing the "A" and seeing whether it sounds like the same note as your voice. But, anyway, this is the same process whether you sing with "Do, Sol", or "hum, hum", so I may not understand the question.... – Bruce Fields Jan 5 '16 at 21:52
  • I don't recommend using a tuner. Do you have a piano or keyboard? If you need to, then use one of those. – Mark Jan 6 '16 at 3:43
0

When I went to school for music, my professor suggested we all use musictheory.net. They have a bunch of different excercises that help with ear training. I suggest atleast looking at it.

  • I tried humming. Once when I had a guitar tuner at hand. I found out that I'm humming or to flat or sharp. That's why in my opinion do as Mark says. Then your sure, the pitch is correct. – Nachmen Jan 6 '16 at 5:42

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.