2

Every day I try to pick apart a new song.

First I try to get the melody. Then the chords. Then I attempt a functional analysis. Finally I try to zoom out a bit further and "see what is going on".

But frequently I find myself in unfamiliar territory. For example yesterday I was trying Scarborough Fair and it doesn't fit into any pattern that is familiar to me.

Is it appropriate to ask a question pertaining to particular song or passage on this forum?

I suspect not, because it would create lots of "what is this device?" type questions.

But regardless, I would like to know what other resources are available on the Internet.

While this might for foul of SO's "No list type questions" guideline, I think such a list would be of value to many.

Could responders please put one resource per answer? Then the best resources will eventually float towards the top through the voting engine...

closed as off-topic by Richard, Matthew Read Feb 15 '18 at 21:13

  • This question does not appear to be about music practice, performance, composition, technique, theory, or history within the scope defined in the help center.
If this question can be reworded to fit the rules in the help center, please edit the question.

3

I think this is a good place for such questions. I've posted the question about harmonic analysis on this forum, and got a satisfactory answer.

In terms of resources, check out Hooktheory. You can find there many harmonic analysis of popular songs.

1

Scarborough Fair, being a traditional (some say it's a traditional English folk song) was composed using a scale (Dorian) and chords built on that scale -if you began to study music theory with a basic classical harmony analysys, I suppose this song lacks a Dominant (is this the question?) , well - I think it's pretty safe to say that the "D major" here, has got the same function of a dominant, to prepare the listener to feel that soon the song is going to come back to the tonic (which is E minor) - Dorian is a minor scale and it's been used for ages in all Europe, since, but also before Middle Ages

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.