Apologies- aged learner here!! Can anyone explain to me the relationship ( if any ?!) between the melody line of a song and the most suitable strum pattern to accompany it? I can read music and do "get" time signatures, beats and half beats ( in the melody line) etc but this particular relationship continues to bug me!! Appreciate the chord played relates pretty directly to the melody ( although that isn't exactly simple either is it?!!) but it's the strum/rhythm bit that's the problem!!
Just to be clear, you're asking about how the rhythm of the melody line relates to the strumming rhythm of a guitar accompaniment?– Todd WilcoxMay 10, 2016 at 21:16
Yes basically that's what is puzzling me!– RogerMay 11, 2016 at 7:44
Roger - does this one help: music.stackexchange.com/questions/2055/…– Doktor Mayhem ♦May 11, 2016 at 17:04
Or in fact any of those Related questions to the right --->– Doktor Mayhem ♦May 11, 2016 at 17:05
I would say there is not a direct relationship between the notes chosen for the melody and the strumming pattern that would be most appropriate for the song. They are two completely different elements of the music and are chosen by the composer independently.
The rhythm and choice of notes used in the song or musical piece are but two of the many elements that all work together to convey the feeling or effect the composer wishes to convey in the piece.
Every song or musical composition contains certain basic elements. Some of these elements include melody, tempo, rhythm, harmony and dynamics (how soft our loud a part is played). They all work together to make a song unique. The fact that there are so many different elements that can be varied with each song allows us to use the same 12 pitches in Western music to compose our melodies - yet have millions of unique songs that all sound different.
When playing rhythm guitar, you generally provide both harmony (by choosing which chords to go with the melody notes) - and rhythm - (which is established primarily by the strumming pattern). You can also set the tempo and establish the dynamics of the song by the way you strum the guitar.
All of these variables combine with the notes in the melody to make the song unique. If the particular notes used in the melody in any way suggested a particular strumming pattern and thus a particular rhythm - more (perhaps even most) songs would sound the same. After all - in a given key we only have 7 notes to choose from for our melody. But we have an infinite number of potential strumming patterns, tempos, or ways to alter the dynamics of any given musical piece which enable us to use the same melody notes to convey entirely different musical ideas.
So by being creative and applying a unique rhythm, tempo and other elements to each song, we can use the same 7 notes in any given key to create thousands of unique songs. So it's good that as composers we are not restricted to certain strumming patterns based on the notes in the melody.
Thank you very much indeed for taking the time to answer my ( probably stupid!) question so comprehensibly! I really appreciate it May 11, 2016 at 7:49
@Roger - no question is a stupid question except the one you fail to ask. Music theory can be quite confusing which is why music majors can spend 4 or more years in college learning it. I continue to learn things about music theory and practice on this site. May 11, 2016 at 18:08
Generally speaking the strum pattern (and other accompaniment techniques) will depend more on the generic characteristics of the song (tempo, style, genre) and the effect you want to achieve than the particulars of the melody (although sometimes, for momentary effect, a particular combination of strummed chords and sung words may be used).
For the most basic technique start by one "strum" downwards for each beat on the measure, regardless of the melody. In fact, if you're singing yourself at the same time, you'll need to make an effort not to let your singing compromise the regular pattern of the strumming. Separate guitar practise may be needed.
Then divide the beat in one down and one up for each beat. Then combine the two, e.g., for 4/4 time signature (V= down strum, ^= up strum):
1------2------3------4------ V V V V ^
This will not win you a job replacing Edge in U2, but it will give you something to start with. Try different combinations and try to adapt to the song according to your taste. In no time will be doing it naturally and more complex patterns may come to you naturally. If not (or even if they do), pick a song you like and look for an "how to play" tutorial in youtube.
Putting an up-strum after beat 4 is probably the worst place to have it, for a beginner. That's where the chord is likely to change, so it gives less time for that to happen cleanly.– TimMay 11, 2016 at 6:21
I suppose you're right Tim, I meant that only as a very basic step to practice the right hand. May 11, 2016 at 8:03
Many thanks for that! Overall I think I'm rather relieved that the relationship is not in any way a fixed one and thanks to your kindness and that if other posters I think I understand things better now and will take on board all the advice regarding practicing strum patterns as they are clearly very very important- more than I had really realised! Thanks again I am most grateful for your help! May 11, 2016 at 8:04
The strum pattern. Pattern is important. A pattern is something that repeats, so a strum pattern, specially in pop music, is going to be basically the same thing for each bar. Pretty well regardless of the rhythm of the melody. It needs to complement the melody, of course, but it rarely copies the melody rhythm.
As joseem states, it's basically (in a 4/4) down, down, down, down, on the beats 1,2,3,4. Upstrums can, and do go in between these - after all, your hand is going in that direction anyway for the next downstrum - so it is there to be used to strum up. So now, we have 8 strums per bar, if needed.
This alone gives hundreds of different patterns, by sometimes putting an upstrum (or 2, or 3!) in, sometimes leaving a downstrum out, etc. A simple reggae strum would be purely upstrums, leaving out all the downs. You need to experiment, maybe with a metronome or drum machine, with a lot of there patterns, not necessarily with a particular song in mind, but just with a couple of chords, to establish what's available. Find a few that you enjoy, and they may well bring certain songs to mind.
Very much appreciate your advice on this. It's increasingly evident to me that rhythm is perhaps the most crucial issue to get to grips with when learning guitar rather than obsessing about chord patterns and fancy riffs !! Problem I find with metronomes is that they don't differentiate between say 3/4 or 4/4 or indeed any other time signature which is also critical to the rhythm of the piece- like they're too monotonous! Thanks again so much for troubling to answer my question. May 11, 2016 at 8:00
Even when you're using a metronome it's good practice to count out loud while you're getting yourself familiar with the rhythm. As Tim said you could also use a drum machine. This may be better for you. There are lots available for smartphones. May 11, 2016 at 10:28
@Roger - I have a few metronomes which can be programmed to go ping.click,click for 3/4 or ping,click,click,click for 4/4, etc. Both mechanical and electronic. Still prefer drum machines, though...– TimMay 11, 2016 at 11:35