1

Chicago is one of my favourite Meg & Dia songs (RIP 2012). I've tabbed out a few of their songs and figured out their keys and such, but this one seems to be more than your standard vi-IV-I-V stuff. It goes like this:

Verse :

    Cmaj7 Bm Bb Am

Chorus:

    Dm7 Gm7 Cmaj7

-

    Dm7 Gm7 

-

    Cmaj7 Bm Am7

    Eb D

Outro:

    Eb Dm Cm

    Fm Bb7

I'm 99% sure these are the chords I hear (link to the song). I'm confused between the C and C minor scales, some of the chords are from these keys but others just don't seem to fit, or at least I can't make them to.

Thanks !

GST_Diandre

3

You've just learned something important. Not all the chords in a song have to fit into one scale. And it's often pointless to MAKE them fit by inventing a constant string of mini-modulations.

Look at how those chords DO fit together. C^, Bm, Bb, Am has a bass line that walks down. That's a strong enough reason for the sequence.

3

The 'theory' is that chords from parallel major and minor work well together. Nearly all of these chords are from C major/C minor, which bears this out - except - Bm. So, as Laurence states, not EVERY chord HAS to fit in a certain key, it's just that most times, they do.

  • Or even, once we're past very simple songs, most times they don't! – Laurence Payne Jan 4 '18 at 22:08

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.