1

I'm trying to figure out what's going on in David Bowie's song, Battle for Britain. (The intro ends at 0:35 or so.) These are the chords, near as I can tell. One chord per measure.

En
B   F#   A    A 
B   F#   A    A 
B   F#   A    A 
B   F#   A    A 
G   F#   E    E
G   F#   E    E
G   F#   A  (skipped measure)
C   G  Bbmaj7 F  
En...

The first 4 lines follow the common I-V-bVII sequence (or V-I-IV if you prefer).

The next 2 raise the tension by switching things up somehow. I think maybe it's good to say the key changes? Changes to E and there's some kind of chromatic planing, or is the F# after G a substitution for something, or...?

In the next line it goes to A instead of E, and somehow it sounds like a new key all of a sudden! It sounds like the A suddenly acts like secondary dominant V/V in G. Then on the next line you can say IV in G follows, as commonly occurs after a V/V in pop music.

On this next line you then have IV-I-bIII-bVII, similar to the common I-V-bVII-IV except the tonal center is on the second chord.

So what's going on in lines 5-7? Specifically, what's happening to the tonal center? Can the rest of my analysis be improved?

2

I'm inclined to say that you could view those two phrases as bVI - V - IV in B major.

If you consider the vocal part in those phrases - all the vocal melodies use G#, A# (this is the crucial note), and B which fits the B major pitch set which was the key from before. If you're hearing the tonal center around E in those measures I think you could say it's E Lydian, being that the pitch set fits B Ionian and the mode centered on E is the fourth mode of B Ionian.

Hope this helps!

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.