I watched a lesson where the teacher said that if we want to harmonize the fourth grade of C Major with 7/11 chord, we should use #11 (i.e. F maj 7 #11). I could not understand the reasons well. Is it because of that flat in F? If so, is this an exception?

Regards, Kiko

  • 1
    .. the fourth grade of C? Explain this, terminology, please. – Neil Meyer Dec 8 '16 at 12:55
  • @NeilMeyer I assume the OP means "(scale) degree". – 11684 Dec 8 '16 at 22:50

I've never heard that particular terminology ("fourth grade of C") either, but I'm guessing the rationale is this:

If you're harmonizing an F chord, normally the key of F major has a B-flat. However, since you're harmonizing an F chord in the key of C major, you will not use a B-flat, since B-flat is not in the key of C.

As such, this F major chord will not have a B-flat, but rather a B-natural, which is the #11. (Similarly, the maj7, E-natural, is in the key of C as well.)

It may be helpful here to note "the rule of seven": if a chord extension is higher than 7, just subtract 7 to get a quicker idea of what interval that extension is. For instance, if you have trouble remembering what an 11th above a pitch is, just think 11-7=4 to realize that an 11th is really just a 4th above. (Obviously there are some concerns here with octave displacement, but this is just a fast way to determine the pitch name [or pitch class, if you've heard that term].) Similarly, a 13th is just (13-7=6) a sixth above.

  • Sorry, not a native speaker, and I wrote it quickly. By fourth grade of C major, i meant F lydian ( : Richard, thank you for the explanation! ( : – Kiril Mladenov Dec 8 '16 at 13:03
  • 1
    No worries, your English is terrific! – Richard Dec 8 '16 at 13:19
  • I reckon the chord is called 7/#11 rather than 7/11, for the reason you state. It works for all keys, just that with root F in a chord, the Bb gets cancelled by the # to be just plain old B, which possibly caused confusion. '4th grade of C' must be IV, but a strange nomenclature indeed. Not sure if Lydian is relevant? +1. – Tim Dec 8 '16 at 16:57

I think the teacher is just alerting you to the fact that when a 4th (11th) is ADDED to a chord (as distinct to being used as a suspension) it's a lot less painful when sharpened. And that this, a IV7(#11), is a particularly nice sound! Note it, and add it to your box of tricks.enter image description here

  • 1
    (Note that OP mentioned Fmaj7, so if we follow that it would be E-natural instead of E-flat.) – Richard Dec 8 '16 at 19:01
  • Perhaps. He mentioned 7/11, and '7' in a chord name is minor unless stated otherwise. But there are so many systems of chord description... – Laurence Payne Dec 8 '16 at 19:12

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.