2

I've heard that it's good to sing what you play on a piano. Singing chord is not possible but bass lines would be. Bass lines are sometimes played a octave lower than what a male person can sing but I guess you could transpose them octave higher. Does anyone have any proven evidence that singing bass lines help with learn to play them on the piano? and if so did they have to sing them an octave higher due to bass lines being too low in range?

  • 2
    You haven't specified a style of music, but when I hear this advice applied to jazz it usually refers to singing a melody or improvised line. The idea is to develop a connection to the music via the breath to make your phrasing more natural. On piano you can play notes endlessly, but singers and horn players have to take breaths. Singing the lines as you play piano can result in more natural phrasing. – vjones Dec 18 '16 at 4:09
  • 1
    Singing any musical line helps you play music rather than just notes. The phrasing that comes "naturally" to fingers on a keyboard is quite different from what comes "naturally" when singing. The point of the exercise is to help you listen critically to what you are playing, think about it, and play the music the way you want to play it, not just the way that your fingers find easiest. – user19146 Dec 18 '16 at 8:18
4

Yes, singing any line before and as you play will help. George Benson is one to listen to for example.The octave doesn't matter a jot. In fact, if you think about it, females will have to sing that bass line an extra octave higher in most cases.

If you get used to trying to sing a line prior to playing it, it'll improve sight reading as well as phrasing and playing generally. When improvising, I get students to sing a phrase in the key they're in, then play it. Sort of 'in their mind's ear'.

If you're starting out learning piano, then playing and singing any line, simultaneously and separately, will implant it into memory far better than just playing it with fingers. Come to think of it, it works for all levels, advanced as well. Not so easy on sax or trumpet,for the former, though...

1

'Sing it before you play it' is not, on piano at any rate, much about hitting the right note (more so on other instruments perhaps, but on piano you don't have to 'make' the note the way a wind player does), but it can help with playing the right rhythms. It's a lot easier to sing a phrase in time than to play it in time if you're fumbling to put your fingers on the right notes!

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.