3

In the classical repertoire, there are some works where gender "roles" seem to be fluid, but others where they are not.

For instance, Schubert's Winterreise is performed by both men and women. However, even when there are implied "characters," the tendency is inconsistent: as an example, Schubert's Die schöne Müllerin is almost always sung by men, while Mahler's Lieder eines fahrenden Gesellen is split almost equally between men's and women's voices in performance.

Are there any general guidelines that govern when a piece can be "transposed" between men's and women's voices?

  • Some vocal music were written for specific people. It would be presumptuous of you to sing a piece composed for a woman. – Neil Meyer Dec 26 '16 at 15:49
  • So be presumptious. Even easier these days, now choice of gender identity is a thing! – Laurence Payne Dec 26 '16 at 16:32
2

Good Question. It prompted me to search and find this interesting read.

Although I enjoy and have studied a wide spectrum of music, my preferred specialty for several years has been Baroque vocal music. Over the last generation or two, singers, directors, and audiences gradually have shown an increased interest in the vocal works written for castrati. Because the era of castrati is long gone, a frequent solution has been to cast such roles with women. These efforts continue to be met with relative success or failure depending upon the quality of the voices and the training of the singers.Not surprisingly, the casual listener conveniently equates high voices with female and low voices with male. If, for example, a male sings with a high tessitura, whether naturally or with falsetto, some listeners fail to analyze what they hear beyond their simple conclusion. I recall during one of my lectures, a music professor and Julliard graduate exclaimed, “Why, he sounds just like a woman!” One irritated response was, “No, he does not!” I suggest that there are two major factors in one’s ability to discern male voices from female voices other than tessitura: musical experience and innate musical sensitivity.

As far as classical theory, there are no specific rules that dictate when and where a male or female should or should not sing a specific part, as long as s/he can "hit the notes." The full read of the article I linked goes more in depth on the differences of timbre. This is the crux of the issue for determining whether to use male or female, child or adult, voices.

What sound are you trying to achieve? What mood are you conveying? Finally, this is art, baby! Some of us males just drop the octave when we're performing a female vocal or singing "Habanera" in the shower...

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.